1 Forsothe Joob answeride, and seide, Whos helpere art thou?
John Chrysostom · AD 407 These words mean, "I do not reprove you for defending the role of God or to say the truth that was needed." However, you should not have condemned me, and, in fact, it is possible to plead in favor of God without allowing, at the same time, Job to be exposed to accusations.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Baldath wanted in his last speech to convince Job by the consideration of divine power, terrible to all, in respect of which no man can make a pretense of justice, and innocence so that he asserts that he has been punished without sin.
2 whether `of the feble, and susteyneste the arm of hym, which is not strong?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 But Job answered and said, Of whom art thou the helper? whether of one that is powerless? or dost thou sustain the arm of him that is not strong?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Men who do not use reason against someone condemned, but cite the power and the wisdom of the judge. They usually do this in favor of the judge. Favor is accorded to someone for two reasons: either because of the defect of power of the one favored, or because of his lack of wisdom. As to the first he says, "Whose helper are you?
3 To whom hast thou youe counsel? In hap to hym that hath not wisdom; and thou hast schewid ful myche prudence.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 To whom hast thou given counsel? perchance to him that hath not wisdom? To 'give counsel to one that is foolish' is an office of charity, to give it to one that is wise, of ostentation; but to give it to Wisdom Itself, of wrongmindedness; and because those who we have said bear the likeness of heretics, by their mode of speech, were administering to ostentation rather than to u…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Then, as for the favor which is shown to someone because of the defect of wisdom, we should consider that this favor is twofold. On the one hand, in that one gives counsel to someone about things to be done, and he speaks to this theme saying, "To whom have you given counsel?" Someone seems to give counsel to another when he defends his cause without reason.
4 Ether whom woldist thou teche? whether not hym, that made brething?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Whom wouldest thou have taught? Was it not Him Who made the breathway? By the 'breathway' we live, by prudence we are wise. But it is ours first to live, and afterwards to be imbued with wisdom; because in order that we have the power to be wise, it is first brought to pass that we should have being. He, then, Who bestowed life, the same doubtless gave prudence as well.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The other way of favoring against the lack of wisdom is to instruct the ignorant man concerning what he must know, and as to this he says, "Whom do you want to teach?", for you seemed to teach God when you brought his power against me, but he who is the cause of all human science does not need to be taught, and so he says, "Was he not the one who made the spirit," who created t…
5 Lo! giauntis weilen vnder watris, and thei that dwellen with hem.
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 "Behold, giants groan under the waters." After proposing the division that he made between power and wisdom, Job puts forward his evidence. He distinguishes the deep and the underworld.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Lo, the giants groan under the waters. For it was fitting that by rebuking he should first beat down the swelling of earthly wisdom, and by instruction afterwards pass on to words replete with mysteries. Thus by 'giants,' either apostate Angels, or all proud men may without objection be understood.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Then, lest Job seem to detract from the power of God in anything, he commends it as much more all encompassing than did Baldath, enumerating the many effects of divine power. He begins from those effects which God powerfully worked in the human race in the time of the flood.
6 Helle is nakid bifor hym, and noon hilyng is to perdicioun.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Hell is naked before Him, and destruction hath no covering. Which same Paul likewise saith, But all things are naked and opened unto His eyes. But by the title of 'hell' and 'perdition' he denoted the devil and all the associates of his condemnation; but Who that One is before whom 'hell is naked,' he goes on with telling.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 One should not believe that divine providence extends only to judging men in this life, and not after death, as the friends of Job seemed to think. To disprove this he then says, "Hell is naked before him," as if to say: The things which happen in hell are clearly seen by him and happen according to his judgment.
7 Which God stretchith forth the north on voide thing, and hangith the erthe on nouyt.
Cosmas Indicopleustes · AD 550 And with regard to the earth it is again written in Job: He that hangeth the earth upon nothing; meaning, that it had nothing underneath it. And David in harmony with this, when he could discover nothing on which it was founded, says: He that hath founded the earth upon its own stability, as if he said, it hath been founded by thee upon itself, and not upon anything else.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He stretcheth out the north over the empty place. [MYSTICAL INTERPRETATION] By the title of the 'north,' in Holy Writ the devil is used to be designated, who with the thought to bind up the hearts of the nations with the iciness of insensibility, said, I will sit also upon the mount of the Covenant, in the sides of the north.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Then he lists the effects of divine providence in natural things, and he begins from the two extremes, from earth and heaven. In each of these something appears instituted from divine power which exceeds human strength. As far as what appears to the senses, heaven seems to be extended above the earth like a kind of tent; earth to be under heaven like the floor of the tent.
8 `Which God byndith watris in her cloudis, that tho breke not out togidere dounward.
Olympiodorus of Alexandria · AD 600 "Binding water in his clouds, and the cloud is not dispersed under it." In fact, if he does not order the clouds to rain, they do not release rain on earth in the quantity that has been ordered by him.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He bindeth up the waters in his thick clouds, that they should not burst forth alike beneath. For what does he call 'the waters' in this place but knowledge; what 'clouds' but the Preachers?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Then he enumerates the effects of divine power in the middle space between heaven and earth. First, in the air, where one finds the wondrous fact that water is lifted up as vapor, is suspended in the air, and does not fall all at once, but drop by drop.
9 `Whych God holdith the cheer of his seete, and spredith abrood theron his cloude.
Olympiodorus of Alexandria · AD 600 "He constrains the elements with his purposes hidden, stretching out his cloud upon them." Heaven is often called "the throne of God" in holy Scripture. Air is placed before the face of heaven. Therefore, he says that God, by containing the air and expanding the clouds, does not allow them to release rain, if not in the measure that he knows to be convenient and useful.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He holdeth back the face of His Throne, and spreadeth His cloud upon it. [LITERAL INTERPRETATION] In the face there is wont to be shewn forth acquaintanceship.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After rain falls from the clouds, some remnants of the vapors remain behind, from which the clouds are formed. These conceal heaven from our point of view which is like the throne of God, according to the last chapter of Isaiah, "Heaven is my throne." (66:1) Expressing this he continues, "He keeps hidden the face of his throne," for he holds back as though hiding the face of he…
10 He hath cumpassid a terme to watris, til that liyt and derknessis be endid.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He hath compassed the waters with bounds, until the light and darkness come to an end. Because very often in Holy Writ, as we said above, by the name of 'waters' peoples are denoted; the Lord compasseth the waters with bounds; because He so tempers the knowledge of mankind: that until the successions of the changing seasons pass away, it cannot perfectly attain to the knowledge…
Ishodad of Merv · AD 850 So God has gathered the waters that were spread on earth at the beginning and has imposed a limit on them. His command has surrounded them like a circle, so that they might not exceed it. He has set a "boundary between light and darkness." This means that he has ordered the light and the darkness to occupy their given times in good harmony and not to prevail on one another.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Then he shows the effect of divine power on the waters when he says, "He has circumscribed a limit on the waters"; for the waters according to the natural order of the elements should cover every place on the earth, but that some part of the earth remains uncovered by the waters is due to divine power, which has set out a boundary for the water covering the earth.
11 The pilers of heuene tremblen, and dreden at his wille.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 The pillars of heaven tremble, and are astonished at His nod. [MYSTICAL INTERPRETATION] What else does he call 'the pillars of heaven' but the holy Angels, or the principal preachers of the Church, over whom in the heavenly world the whole structure of the spiritual edifice increasing arose, as Holy Scripture elsewhere bears witness, saying, Him that overcometh will I make a pi…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After listing the effects of the divine power on corporeal creatures he shows its effect on spiritual creatures which he calls the pillars of heaven, because their duty, in effect, is to preside over the movements of the heaven.
12 In the strengthe of hym the sees weren gaderid togidere sudeynly, and his prudence smoot the proude.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 In His might the seas are suddenly gathered together, and His wisdom hath struck the proud one. What else is denoted by the title of the sea save the present world, wherein the hearts of men seeking after earthly things swell with the diverse billows of the thoughts?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since among the angels there are some who fell away from the reverence due to God, about whom he had already spoken, "In his angels he found wickedness" (4:18) as a consequence, he adds a remark making a distinction between the good and evil angels.
13 His spiryt ournede heuenes, and the crokid serpent was led out bi his hond, ledynge out as a mydwijf ledith out a child.
Ephrem the Syrian · AD 373 These words eloquently signify the perceptible serpent that must be annihilated by Christ's death. He calls Satan a fleeing and deserting serpent in order to indicate his flight from the company of the heavenly powers, and also because he hoped to escape the punishment of his crime.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 His Spirit garnished the heavens. [MYSTICAL INTERPRETATION] What 'heavens,' saving those concerning whom it is written, The heavens are telling the glory of God? Which 'heavens His Spirit garnished' then, when It 'filled' them.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Therefore, the spiritual gifts for the good angels were increased as he fell, and so he says, "his spirit has adorned the heavens," that is, he has adorned the heavenly spirits with the adornment of spiritual gifts.
14 Lo! these thingis ben seid in partie of `hise weyes; and whanne we han herd vnnethis a litil drope of his word, who may se the thundur of his greetnesse?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Lo, these things have been spoken for part of His ways; and whilst we scarcely hear a little drop of His words, who shall be able to look on the thunder of His Majesty? What is meant in this place by the designation of the 'ways,' but the Lord's modes of acting? Hence too the Lord saith by the Prophet; For My ways are not as your ways.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Lest anyone think that these effects, although they are great, are equal to divine power, he says, "Lo, these things have been said about his ways," of the works by which we ascend to the knowledge of God and God communicates himself in some way to us.