1 Forsothe Eliphat Themanytes answeride, and seide,
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 Holy Job had not only shown that Zophar's words were ridiculous but also had reproved all his friends in common. They all thought that wisdom had to be judged according to the limits of their age. Since he had also discussed many issues concerning both human and divine nature, Eliphaz gets offended.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Chap. xv. 1. Then answered Eliphaz the Temanite, and said, Should a wise man answer as if speaking into the wind, and fill his belly with burning?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After hearing Job's response, Eliphaz does not answer the depth of his reasoning but tries to calumniously misrepresent certain words Job has spoken and interpret them according to their superficial meaning, not the depth of their meaning.
2 Whether a wise man schal answere, as spekynge ayens the wynd, and schal fille his stomac with brennyng, `that is, ire?
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 "Will the wise answer as if he speaks in the wind, or will he fill his stomach with ardor?" [Eliphaz] wants to demonstrate that Job's longwinded speech is a proof of foolishness and that the words Job said were dictated by anger and not suggested by reason.
3 For thou repreuest hym bi wordis, which is not lijk thee, and thou spekist that, that spedith not to thee.
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 "You accuse with your words him who is not equal to you and say what is not profitable to you." Your purification is an accusation against God. In fact, if you are afflicted undeservedly, he who is afflicting you is undoubtedly accused of iniquity.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Whence Eliphaz adds; Thou reprovest with words him that is not equal to thee, and thou speakest what is not expedient for thee. Now they suppose that no one has the fear of the Lord, saving him whom they can draw into the foolishness of their own confession.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He next reproves him for saying, "I want to dispute with God," (13:3) and again, "Spare me in only two things and then I will not hide myself from your face and so on." (13:20) In this reproach he cites him for many things. First, for pride because he contends against someone who is greater than he is.
4 As myche as is in thee, thou hast avoidid drede; and thou hast take awey preyeris bifor God.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Hence he adds, Yea, thou castest off fear, and hast taken prayer before God. 'Taken' means 'taken away;' as if he said in plain terms, 'Presuming on Thine own righteousness, thou scornest to implore the grace of Thy Creator.' For when heretics do not find real evils to urge against the good, they feign things to reproach them with, that they may seem righteous, and it very ofte…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He shows why it is not advantageous to debate with God because this sort of dispute excludes two most necessary things. The first of these is the fear of God. For he who fears someone does not presume to discuss contentiously with him.
5 For wickidnesse hath tauyt thi mouth, and thou suest the tunge of blasfemeris.
Hesychius of Jerusalem · AD 450 Because Job reproached his friends with confidence, they were irritated and hurt. This did not demonstrate any arrogance before God. In fact, since Job trusted in his own innocence, he did not take seriously at all the vain power of his accusers.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Whence it is still further added, For thine iniquity teacheth thy mouth, and thou followest the tongue of the crafty. 'Iniquity teaches the mouth,' when there is conceived by a bad life somewhat to be spoken of a worse kind.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Job had not disputed with God from pride, but out of confidence in the truth. But Eliphaz rashly judged this to flow from wickedness and so he then says, "For your wickedness has taught your tongue," as if to say: It is apparent from the effect that you blaspheme and so he then says, "and you imitate the tongue of blasphemers." In reality, the man who blasphemes denies the just…
6 Thi tunge, and not Y, schal condempne thee, and thi lippis schulen answere thee.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 6. Thine own mouth shall condemn thee, and not I; yea, thine own lips shall answer thee. For because they suppose that the evils of adversity break out in consequence of the erroneousness of confession; they say that 'her own lips shall answer her,' so that fault of utterances should be the cause of the scourge. But sometimes they desire to repress it as if by reasoning.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 So Eliphaz wishes to condemn Job for arguing and he first says that Job had spoken such manifest evil that no other reproof is necessary. His very words themselves show his evil intent. He expresses this saying, "Your mouth will condemn you and not I, and your lips will answer for you," as if to say: Your words need no other answer but they destroy themselves.
7 Whether thou art borun the firste man, and art formed bifor alle little hillis?
John Chrysostom · AD 407 Eliphaz is just about to say, did you by any chance exist before the entire world, so that you learned about the most ancient times? Or did you learn anything from the mouth of God? You are not superior to us in knowledge at all. Since you had said that "wisdom is found in a long time," are you not caught in a trap now?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 7, 8. Art thou the first man that was born? or wast thou made before the hills? Hast thou heard the secret of God? and shall His wisdom be inferior to thee? Whence Eliphaz sets himself to reprove blessed Job as it were on principles of reason, saying, Art thou the first man that was born? or wast thou made before the hills? Hast thou heard the secret of God?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Still he shows that the argument he used was unfitting in many ways. First, by comparison of Job to all creatures. For if any creature could argue with God, this would be really fitting only for the first and most excellent of creatures, a condition which does not befit God and so Eliphaz says, "Were you born the first man and formed before all the hills," so that for this reas…
8 Whether thou herdist the counsel of God, and his wisdom is lower than thou?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Second, by comparison with God. For one can dispute with someone about his deeds fittingly when he knows the reason why the one with whom he is arguing acts. He can know this in two ways. In one way, by learning it from him. In another way, by judging the deeds of the other from a higher wisdom. Neither of these ways is fitting to Job in the comparison of man to God.
9 What thing knowist thou, whiche we knowen not? What thing vndurstondist thou, whiche we witen not?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 9. What knowest thou that we know not? What understandest thou which is not in us? Which same sentences plainly shew in what exaltation of mind all that comes forth, which sounds as if it were for defence of the Lord.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Third, he shows it in comparison to other men. But Job does not in fact seem to be any wiser than others from confidence in the possession of a higher knowledge so that he can presume to dispute with God. So he then says, "What do you know," from faith or revelation, "that we do not know?" "What do you understand," by natural knowledge, "that we do not know?"
10 Bothe wise men and elde, myche eldre than thi fadris, ben among vs.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 10. With us are both the gray headed and very aged men, much elder than thy father. That all Heretics are gone out of the Holy Church Universal, John testifies, when he says, They went out from us, but they were not of us.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 But since Job could boast of knowledge received from others, he then says, "Both old men," in dignity of knowledge and life, "and the elders," in time, "are much older among us than your fathers," than your teachers from whom you received knowledge, or according to the literal sense, your ancestors.
11 Whether it is greet, that God coumforte thee? But thi schrewid wordis forbeden this.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 11. Is it a great thing that God should console thee? But thine evil words prevent this. As if he said to him in plain words; 'If thou wouldest amend thy profession of faith, thou mightest long ago have had consolation in thy scourges.'
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Fourth, on the part of Job himself, he shows his dispute with God has not been fitting. First, because it was harmful to him expanding what he had already said, "You say what is not profitable for you." (v.3) So, he says, "Is it a great thing for God to console you?" He means here: It is easy for God to lead you back to a state of prosperity, "for he both wounds, and he binds u…
12 What reisith thin herte thee, and thou as thenkynge grete thingis hast iyen astonyed?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 12. Why does thine heart lift thee up, and hast thou thine eyes astonished as thinking of great things? Often the mind of the righteous is so suspended in contemplating things on high, that outwardly their face seems to have been struck with stupefaction.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Second, he shows that the debate was vain and proud, expanding something he had said already, "Will the wise man answer as though he were speaking to the wind?" (v.2) So he then says, "Why does your heart lift you up," in pride to make you presume so much on your wisdom.
13 What bolneth thi spirit ayens God, that thou brynge forth of thi mouth siche wordis?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 13. Why dost thy spirit swell against God, that thou lettest such words go out of thy mouth? Very often when the righteous are afflicted with any woes, they are forced to confess their works, as blessed Job had done, who after just living was pressed down by the strokes of the rod; but when the unrighteous hear their sayings, they think that they are uttered in self-exalta…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Third, he shows that this dispute was presumptuous and impious, also explaining a previous statement, "You blame with words someone who is not equal to you." (v.3) Here then he says, "What causes your spirit to swell against God so that you speak words like this from your mouth," with which you start an argument with God?
14 What is a man, that he be with out wem, and that he borun of a womman appere iust?
Olympiodorus of Alexandria · AD 600 "Who is the person," Eliphaz asks, "who can be blameless or can proclaim, I am righteous?" If, in fact, those who are very holy, both men and angels, and the purity itself of heaven before the judgment of the most pure God appear to be unclean, what should we say about the damnable and impure human being who drinks iniquity like a draught?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 14. What is man, that he should be clean? MORAL INTERPRETATION For hereby alone that he is called 'man' he is described as earthly and weak; for man is so named ['homo' from 'humus,' as Hebrew 'Adam'] from the earth. And how is it possible for him to be free from stain, who being made of earth of his own will fell into infirmity?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After Eliphaz had censured Job for his provoking God to argue which he thought pertained to presumption of wisdom, he now censures him for presumption of justice because he had said, "If I am judged, I know I would be found just." (13:18) Eliphaz attacks this statement first because of the frailty of the human condition in which man avoids sin with difficulty and so he says, "W…
15 Lo! noon among hise seyntis is vnchaungable, and heuenes ben not cleene in his siyt.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 15. Behold, among His saints there is no one that is unchangeable; the heavens are not clean in His sight. MYSTICAL INTERPRETATION He repeated that with the title of 'the heavens,' which he before denoted by the appellation of the 'Saints.' For it is written concerning those very Saints; The heavens are telling the glory of God; all of whom have by nature in themselves cha…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Second, he attacks the same statement by comparing him to more noble creatures, and so he then says, "Look! Among his holy ones," the angels, "not one is unchangeable," from his own nature, but they can only be turned away from sin because of the gift of divine grace.
16 How myche more a man abhomynable and vnprofitable, that drynkith wickidnesse as water?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 16. How much more abominable and useless is man, which drinketh iniquity like water? He who first said it was impossible that man should of himself be clean from sin, and righteous, calls him 'abominable' and 'useless;' 'abominable' on account of the uncleanness of his stain, but 'useless' on account of the unrighteousness of an imperfect life; who however may be understoo…
Ishodad of Merv · AD 850 "He will drink iniquity like water." The author says these words in order to show that [human beings] enjoy uttering blasphemies.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Third, he attacks the same statement from the personal condition of Job himself, as a conclusion to the major (premise above in v. 15) "How much more abominable," through sin, "and useless," by the failure of justice, "is the man who drinks evil like water," i.e. who commits evil as if it were nothing and without any consideration.
17 I schal schewe to thee, here thou me; Y schal telle to thee that, that Y siy.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 17. I will shew it thee, hear me; and that which I have seen I will declare to thee. All arrogant persons have this proper to them, that when they have a right notion, though the thing be little, they wrest it to serve the turn of pride, and by the same act whereby from understanding they might to themselves be raised higher, from swoln pride they only fall into the pit of…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After Eliphaz had censured Job for provoking God to argument and presuming his own justice, he now censures him about the words he used in the argument and especially for his statement, "Do you think of me as your enemy?
18 Wise men knoulechen, and hiden not her fadris.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 18. Wise men confess, and do not hide their fathers. And at once they leap out in praise of them, and boast that they had been as it were the only rulers of the Church. Hence it is yet further added, Unto whom alone the earth was given, and the stranger passed not among them.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Besides, I will not be embarrassed to tell you what I have heard from others, putting them forward as my authority, because "Wise men confess and do not hide their fathers," from whom they learned wisdom. It is truly the lot of the ignorant and the proud to attribute what they have learned from others to themselves.
19 To whiche aloone the erthe is youun, and an alien schal not passe bi hem.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 Eliphaz adds, "No stranger marched against them," that is, the wise are those who enjoy peace and transmit it to their descendants. "No stranger marched against them." This means they made no war nor saw any fight nor knew any revolt, but they stood with nobility and bravery. They did not only survive but also possessed great force and power and enjoyed a profound peace.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He then shows why they should not be hidden because of their dignity saying, "The earth has been given to men alone." This statement can be related indifferently and in the same sense either to the wise men or to their fathers, whom he also wishes to be understood as wise.
20 A wickid man is proud in alle hise daies; and the noumbre of hise yeeris and of his tirauntrie is vncerteyn.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 "All the life of the ungodly," he says, "is spent in anguish," and when they experience peace, their conscience will know this anguish. "The years granted to the oppressors," who are unjust, "are numbered," he says, because the tyrants are ephemeral.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 20. The wicked man feels proud all his days. LITERAL AND MORAL INTERPRETATION The Elect also are apt to feel pride in some of their thoughts and actions. But because they are Elect persons, they cannot feel pride all their days, because before they end their lives, they turn their hearts from self-exaltation to the fearing of humility.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After he has gotten the attention of his listener, he then tries to answer the arguments which Job had used in debate. He understood Job to have said two things in these arguments.
21 The sown of drede is euere in hise eeris, and whanne pees is, he supposith euere tresouns.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 "Just when he seems to be at peace, his overthrow will come." Here Job learns that war comes from above, and there will be no change in his misfortunes.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 21. A dreadful sound is alway in his ears, and when there is peace, he suspecteth plots. But there is nothing more happy than simplicity of heart, in that in proportion as it shews forth innocency towards others, there is nothing it dreads to meet with from others.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 From this lack of certainty, suspicion and fear arise. He describes this suspicion and fear as a consequence saying, "The sound of terror is always in the ear of that man," since he is threatened by every rumor thinking some attack is being prepared against him. It is as though he confides in no one.
22 He bileueth not that he may turne ayen fro derknessis to liyt; and biholdith aboute on ech side a swerd.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 "He has been appointed to be food for vultures." "He has already been given over to the power of the sword." Notice this again. His death is pitiful. It is not conformed to the common law of nature but is the result of violence, war and battle.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 22. He believeth not that he shall return out of darkness, and he is waited for of the sword. For because he believes himself to be on all sides stricken from ambush, despairing of salvation, he is ever growing on in wickedness. Now there are times too when this ungodly man turns his eyes to judgments from above as well, and dreads their coming upon him.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Now when one has fears about some of his enemies, he can hope to escape even if he is defeated for a while with the help of his friends.
23 Whanne he stirith hym to seke breed, he woot, that the dai of derknessis is maad redi in his hond.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 23. When he has stirred himself to seek bread, he knoweth that the day of darkness is ready in his hand. For 'bread' is the wages of the present life, and 'the day of darkness' is taken for the time of vengeance.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Now although a tyrant fears all strangers, he still can sometimes confide in the members of his family or his household with whom he lives securely. But when his evil is beyond all measure, he fears even the members of his own household with whom he lives and so the text continues, "When he goes to look for bread, he knows that the day of darkness is at hand," i.e.
24 Tribulacioun schal make hym aferd, and angwisch schal cumpas hym, as a kyng which is maad redi to batel.
Ephrem the Syrian · AD 373 This means that pain and anguish catches [the wicked] in the middle, just like in a field where on one side a king threatens with inimical banners and on the other side pillaging robbers impend, so that his mind and soul cannot be at rest.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 24. Trouble shall make him afraid, straits shall besiege him, as a king ready to the battle. In all that the wicked man does, he is hedged in with anguish, and tribulation, and straits; in that his soul is confounded with anxiety and misgiving.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since he has such fears of everyone, he does not rest but is always plotting something against those whom he fears. Therefore, the occasion of fear is ever multiplied for him, and so he says, "Tribulation will terrify him," threatening him by the actions of others, "and anguish wall him it," because he fears danger from every quarter.
25 For he helde forth his hond ayens God, and he was maad strong ayens Almyyti God.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 25, 26. For he hath stretched out his hand against God, and is strengthened against the Almighty; He runneth upon Him with erected neck, and he is armed with a stout neck. These things are more plainly understood of the head of the wicked himself, i.e.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He next shows why the tyrannical, evil man goes astray in such great unhappiness caused by fear saying, "For truly he extended his hand against God," by acting against God, "and he fortified himself against the Almighty," i.e. because he used the power given him against God.
26 He ran with neck reisid ayens God, and he was armed with fat nol.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He shows how Job has acted against God saying, "He ran against him with his head erect," proudly. For man resists God whom he ought to serve in humility most through pride.
27 Fatnesse, that is, pride `comyng forth of temporal aboundaunce, hilide his face, `that is, the knowyng of vndurstondyng, and outward fatnesse hangith doun of his sidis.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 27. Fatness hath covered his face. For the sight is in the face, wherein too is the first more honourable part of the body. Therefore the best of the mind is not unjustly denoted by the face, which wherever we turn it, there we see.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Pride usually arises from an abundance of temporal goods, and so the text continues, "he is furnished with a fat neck," by acting proud against God. For fat is caused by an abundance of humors and so is an image for an abundance of temporal goods.
28 He schal dwelle in desolat citees, and in deseert, `ethir forsakun, housis, that ben turned in to biriels.
Olympiodorus of Alexandria · AD 600 He describes the absolute solitude of the impious and says that because of their misery, they inhabit desolation instead of prosperous cities and houses. "In fact," Eliphaz says, "their wealth will not last."
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 28. And he dwelleth in desolate communities, and in deserted houses, which are become heaps. For as a 'community' has its name from the intercourse of persons living together in common, 'desolate communities' are the actual throngs of wicked followers, by whose shouts this bad man is commended, when he is hurried away by his wickedness into evil deeds.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After Eliphaz shows the anxieties of fear which the wicked man suffers even when he is in the state of prosperity, he now speaks about the bitter things by which he is consumed when he has been cast down in adversity to answer Job's statement, "Do you write bitter things against me and punish me for the sins of my youth?" (13:26) He places becoming a fugitive as the first of th…
29 He schal not be maad riche, nether his catel schal dwelle stidefastli; nether he schal sende his roote in the erthe,
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 29. He shall not be inhabited, neither shall his substance continue, neither shall he send forth his root into the earth. That which is here expressed, He shall not be inhabited, I have found in some copies, He shall not be enriched; but the sense is not at variance, though the phraseology is at variance.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Second is that he is despoiled of his riches and so he says, "He will not become wealthy," by acquiring new riches, "nor will he preserve his substance," to retain the riches he has already acquired. The third bitter thing is the impossibility of recovering his wealth.
30 nether he schal go awei fro derknessis. Flawme schal make drie hise braunchis, and he schal be takun a wey bi the spirit of his mouth.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 30. He shall not depart out of darkness. If this proud man had been minded to turn back from sin to righteousness, he might 'depart out of darkness.' But because he seeks not the light of righteousness, he does not depart out of darkness.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 To explain this he says, "He will not emerge from the darkness," i.e. from the state of adversity. He gives the reason for not returning to the light when he says, "a flame will dry his branches." For there is still hope of reviving a tree if it has been uprooted as long as its branches remain green because they can be grafted and replanted.
31 Bileue he not veynli disseyued bi errour, that he schal be ayenbouyt bi ony prijs.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 31. Let him not believe, being vainly deceived, that he is to be redeemed with any price. As often as we do alms after sin, we as it were pay a price for bad actions. Whence too it is said by the Prophet concerning him who doeth these things not, He will not give God his propitiation, nor the price of the redemption of the soul.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He cannot hope for any sort of renewal, not even from God whom pride of words offends and so he says, "Let him not trust in vain, deceived that he is deemed by some price," for he must be freed by some help from tribulation.
32 Bifor that hise daies ben fillid, he schal perische, and hise hondis schulen wexe drye;
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 32. Before his days are fulfilled he shall perish, and his hands shall wither. The days foreordained to each individual by the Divine Prescience can neither be increased nor lessened, except it happen that they be so foreknown as either to be longer if they be accompanied with the most perfect works, or shorter with the most wicked, just as Hezekiah obtained increase of da…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He posits as a fourth bitter thing the shortness of his life. So he then says, "He will perish before his days are complete," since he will die before his time may be completed, "and his hands will dry up," for his sons and his relations will fail.
33 he schal be hirt as a vyne in the firste flour of his grape, and as an olyue tre castinge awei his flour.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 33, 34. His cluster shall be spoilt like a vine in the first flower, and like an olive casting its flower. For the congregation of the hypocrite shall be barren. It is to be observed that the Divine Word so speaks of this wicked man in general terms, that yet it comes down to his particular wickedness.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Then he gives an example. "His grapes will be blighted just like the vineyard in first flower." This blighting usually results from frost by which he means exterior persecution. "And as the olive lets its flowers fall," usually from some intrinsic cause which means here the meriting of adversity on the part of the one who suffers.
34 For the gaderyng togidere of an ipocrite is bareyn, and fier schal deuoure the tabernaclis of hem, that taken yiftis wilfuli.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Respecting this merit he says, "what the hypocrite collects is sterile," because what is gathered by the hypocrite bears no fruit, "and fire will devour the tents of those who freely accepts gifts." For things acquired wickedly are sometimes easily destroyed according to divine judgment.
35 He conseyuede sorewe, and childide wickidnesse, and his wombe makith redi tretcheries.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ver. 35. They conceive woe, and bring forth iniquity, and their womb prepareth deceit. For he conceives 'woe,' when he devises wicked things; he 'brings forth iniquity,' when he has begun to fulfil what he has devised; by entertaining envy, he 'conceives woe;' by uttering slanders, he 'brings forth iniquity.' For it is grievous wickedness when he who is wicked strives to make o…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He adds a third sin of deceit. So the text continues, "He conceived pain," because he premeditated in his heart the kind of pain he would inflict on others.