1 And Elihu added and said:—
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 The author of the book, while distributing the chapters of the different speeches to us, connects the words that follow to the beginning.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Eliu also added, and spake thus; Suffer me a little, and I will shew thee. He had already said much, and hopes that he will be borne with yet a little longer; because, namely, haughty men consider that they suffer a heavy loss, if they confine their skill by speaking within brief limits.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Eliud presented two things in the words of Job again which he wanted to argue: first, the fact that he said he was just and the fact that he accused God of injustice in his judgment, according to the interpretation Eliud had given the words of Job. Eliud had disputed against these two ideas above. (cc.
2 Restrain thyself for me a little, and I will shew thee, that, yet—for GOD, there is justification,
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 Since he had stirred the attention of the listeners by discussing the providence of God, he also asks their patience for the things that he is about to say.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 First, he gets his attention saying, "Bear with me a little while," because he intends to dispute briefly against the two ideas in one answer, and so he says, "and I will show you," the truth of the thing about which we are treating. He does not want to seem redundant because he seems to have shown already what he wanted [cc.
3 I will bring my knowledge from afar, and, to my Maker, will I attribute righteousness.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 I will repeat my knowledge from the beginning. But because, on the mention of knowledge, his pride of heart hath displayed itself in his voice, he is plainly discovered to be a haughty person, if he does not quickly conceal himself by some disguise.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since he intends to introduce reasons a second time against both of these ideas, he says, "I will take up my argument from the beginning," for against everything which has been said from the beginning, I will again adduce arguments which support my opinion.
4 For, of a truth—not false, are my words, One of competent knowledge, is with thee.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 For truly my words are without falsehood. Even righteous men, when they see that they cannot be understood by their feeble hearers, are frequently wont to praise the things they say.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He precludes someone saying that what he was about to say did not proceed from true science, but false opinion saying, "For truly my discourses are without deceit," for I will not say anything but what is true and accords with true knowledge. So he says, "and I will show you perfect science," the following proofs will convince you because they seem to come from perfect science.
5 Lo! GOD, is mighty, yet will he not despise, Mighty in vigour of mind;
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 God rejecteth not the mighty, though He Himself is mighty. Some things in the course of this mortal life are hurtful in themselves, some are such from circumstances. Some are hurtful of themselves; as sins and wickednesses. But some things are, now and then, hurtful from circumstances, as temporal power, or the bond of wedlock.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After these introductory remarks he begins to discuss the arguments already adduced by Job. First he argues against the fact that Job had said that he was just. To disprove this he proceeds in this manner: Job had enjoyed great power in the time of his prosperity.
6 He will not keep alive one who is lawless, but, the right of oppressed ones, will he grant;
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 But He saveth not the wicked, and giveth judgment to the poor. Holy Scripture is frequently wont to call the humble, 'poor.' Whence they are mentioned in the Gospel, with the addition, 'spirit,' when it is said, Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. [Matt.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 So he says, "but he does not save the wicked," that is, he damns them. He shows the cause of this damnation saying, "and he grants right judgment to the poor," because he passes judgment on evil powerful men in favor of the poor who have been oppressed by them.
7 He will not withdraw—from a righteous one—his eyes,—but, with kings on the throne, He hath seated men triumphantly, and they have been exalted.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He will not withdraw His eyes from the righteous, but establisheth kings on the throne for ever, and there are they exalted. For God is perhaps believed to have withdrawn His eyes from the righteous, because they are here wounded by the injustice of the unrighteous, and are unavenged.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He does not desist because of power from the assistance of the just, and so he says, "He does not take away from the just," even the powerful man, "his eyes," the gaze of his goodness and mercy, according to Psalm 33, "The eyes of the Lord are on the just." (v.
8 But, if, bound in fetters, they have been captured with cords of affliction,
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 And if they shall be in chains, and bound with the cords of poverty, He will shew them their works, and their wickednesses, because they have been violent. The chains of bondage, are the very detention of their present pilgrimage. Paul had seen, that he was bound by these chains, when he was saying, I have a desire to be dissolved, and to be with Christ. [Phil.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Third, he manifests it because even if they are punished for their sins, he has mercy on them if they wish to do penance, and so he says, "and if the kings were in chains," placed in prison, "and were bound with the bonds of poverty," if they suffered poverty when they were tied up in prison.
9 Then hath he declared to them their deed, and their transgressions—that they were wont to behave themselves proudly;
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Yet to those who have been so constituted in unhappiness, God first confers this benefit of recognizing the past sins for which they have been punished, and so he says, "he will show them their works," for he will make them know what they have done which is unjust.
10 Thus hath he uncovered their ear to a warning, and said—that they should turn from iniquity.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He will open also their ear, to correct them, and will speak to them that they return from iniquity. To 'open the ear from iniquity,' is to lay open the understanding of knowledge. But a man is reproved, and his ear opened, when he feels within him a desire after eternal goods, and acknowledges the sins which he has outwardly committed.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Not only does he force them to recognize their past sins, but he also shows them that they are punished for these sins, and so he says, "He will also open their ears," that is, he will make them understand that God speaks to them in punishing them.
11 If they would hearken, and serve, they should complete their days, in prosperity, and their years, in pleasantness;
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 If they shall hear and observe Him, they shall fulfil their days in good, and their years in glory; but if they shall not hear, they shall pass away by the sword, and shall be consumed with folly. By 'good,' is designated right conduct, but by 'glory,' heavenly recompense. They, then, who study to obey the Divine commands, fulfil their days in good, and their years in glory.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He shows the fruit of this penance when he says, "If they listen," taking it to heart, "and they observe it," completing it with works, they will be brought back to their former state and so "they will complete their days in the good," of virtue and earthly prosperity, "and their years in the glory" of the earth.
12 But, if they would not hearken, by a weapon, should they pass away, and breathe their last, no one knowing.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 "But if they do not listen," if they do not obey this interior inspiration to do penance, "they will pass away by the sword," because they will be led to prison to be killed by the sword, "and they will be consumed," destroyed "in their foolishness," because of their foolishness.
13 Yea, the impious in heart, should store up anger, They should not cry for help, when he bound them.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Hypocrites and crafty men provoke the wrath of God. When mentioning hypocrites, he appropriately subjoins, 'and crafty.' For unless they are crafty in wit, they cannot consistently make pretence of that which they wish to appear. For there are certain faults, which are easily perpetrated even by those of duller sense.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since men sometimes suffer adversities even though their sins are not apparent, he wants to preclude his previously cited opinion being dashed to pieces by this fact. So he interprets them to be pretenders because they make a pretense of justice which they do not have, and are clever inasmuch as they use certain things to do injustice under the guise of justice.
14 Their soul should die in youth, and their life, among the unclean.
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 "They will die in the tempest of their soul, and their life among the effeminate." Since he had said above, "God will not be humble before the powerful," here he has rightly said that the one who through his scorn inflames the wrath of the avenger will die among the effeminate, that is, he deserves to be deprived of all his strength by the misfortunes that will happen to him.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Their soul shall die in a tempest. For they were seeming to live as if in calm, when they were taking care to rejoice in the credit of holiness. But their soul, which used to rejoice in the fatal tranquillity of human praise, dies by a sudden tempest.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Because such men do not do penance in their punishments, they are not freed from adversity, and so he says, "Their soul will die in torment," since they suffer diverse agonies even to death, "and their life" will fail, "among effeminate men," who do not have the power to free themselves from the hand of their oppressors.
15 He would deliver the humbled in his humiliation, and would uncover—in oppression—their ear.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He will deliver the poor from his straitness. The poor is delivered from his straitness, when any humble person is set free from this affliction of his pilgrimage. For he is here oppressed with even continual tribulations, in order that he may be excited to seek for the joy of real consolation. Whence it follows also, And will open his ear in tribulation.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since he had said that God helped the powerful in tribulation, he does not want to seem to say that God is a respecter of persons and so he shows that he confers the same benefit also on the poor. He expresses this saying, "He will snatch the poor man from his anguish," by freeing him from adversity.
16 Yea he might even have allured thee—out of the mouth of straitness, [into] a wide space—no narrowness there,—and, the food set down on thy table, should have been full of fatness.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He will therefore bring thee safely from a narrow opening into a broad place. Every one who forsakes the way of life, and casts himself down into the darkness of sins, plunges himself, as it were, into a well or pitfall.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He applies what he has said already in general to the person of Job (vv.5-12). First, since he has said that God brings salvation to both the poor and the powerful in tribulation (vv.
17 But, with the plea of a lawless one, thou art full, Plea and sentence, will take fast hold.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 But thy cause hath been judged as the cause of the ungodly, thou shall receive thy cause and judgment. The cause of the good, is righteousness.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since he has shown that "God does not cast out the powerful," (v. 5) but the wicked, whereas Job seemed to be cast out by God through many adversities, so he says, "Your cause has been judged as evil," as if to say: You were not punished because you were powerful but as a wicked man.
18 Because there is wrath, [beware] lest he take thee away with a stroke, Then let not, a great ransom, mislead thee.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Let not then anger overcome thee, to oppress any one, neither let the multitude of places bow thee down. In most manuscripts we find 'gifts;' in a few, however, but more ancient, we find 'places.' But since the expression, Let not the multitude of gifts turn thee aside, needs no explanation, we have thought good that that expression should be rather expounded, which seems to be…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 As though this had already happened, he warns him now to bear himself in this situation. Judges sometimes deviate from justice because of anger, and as to this he says, "Do not let anger master you so that you oppress someone," unjustly, when then "you will receive the cause and judgment." Judges also sometimes deviate from justice because they are greedy for graft, and he expr…
19 Will he value thy riches? Nay not precious ore, nor all the forces of strength.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 But frequently, while the mind of a righteous man stands firm in the stronghold of its resolution, while it recovers itself from every dispersion of change, and keeps down whatever superfluously arises within; it is smitten by the very glory of its own rectitude, and is raised up with the pride of presuming on itself.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Judges also sometimes deviate from justice because they are greedy for graft, and he expresses this saying, "nor let a great number of gifts make you waver," in that new situation of authority.
20 Do not pant for the night, when peoples disappear from their place.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Prolong not the night, that people may go up for them. As if the arrogant openly said; Act not so in the darkness of thy ignorance, as to substitute a host of infirm persons in the place of the strong. For by the name 'people' are designated those, who, given up to the common practice, live without restraint in all that they desire.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Sometimes, judges lack justice for the sake of their own comfort and so he says, "Do not lengthen the night," that is, do not permit the justice of a cause to be hidden for a long time but immediately bring the truth to light, and he shows the reason for this when he says, "so that the peoples rise up because of them," strong men, as if to say: Do not defer your judgment in suc…
21 Beware, do not turn unto iniquity, For, this, thou hast chosen rather than affliction.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Decline not to iniquity; for thou hast begun to follow this after misery. Haughty men in truth call this the misery of the Church, because they suspect that its main body is despised by God: and they scorn it with loftier pride, the more they suspect that it is utterly despised by God.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 All these things tend to this conclusion: To avoid injustice in the state of future prosperity. So he says, "Beware that you do not fall into evil," in one of these ways or others. Job could say that this warning was superfluous because he was accustomed to diligently strive after justice, for he had said this in Chapter Twenty Nine (v.
22 Lo, GOD, exalteth himself by his strength, Who like him doth teach?
Ephrem the Syrian · AD 373 And you certainly, he says, were tested so far in the furnace of correction. But God will indeed restore you and will bring you back to your former wealth and dignity.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Behold, God is lofty in His strength, and none is like Him among lawgivers. As if he said plainly, He, Who will appear humble in weakness, remains lofty in strength, Paul also witnessing this, who says, For though He was crucified through weakness, yet He liveth by the power of God. [2 Cor. 13, 4] Of Whom it is rightly subjoined, None is like Him among lawgivers.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 After Eliud rejected the words of Job in which he had said he was just, he here rejects his words because he believed he had spoken against the justice of divine judgment. So he first proposes the sublimity of divine power when he says, "Behold God preeminent in his power," for he has a higher power than everything else.
23 Who enjoined on him his way? and who ever said, Thou hast wrought perversity?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Who will be able to search out His ways? Or who dareth to say to Him, Thou hast wrought iniquity? As if he said; 'How can He be blamed, Whose doing cannot be searched into? For no one judges properly of that, which he knows not. We ought, therefore, to rest the more silent under His judgments, the more we see that we perceive not the reason of His judgments.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Third, he proposes the incomprehensibility of his works when he says, "Who will be able to examine his ways," that is, sufficiently search the nature of his works? From this he concludes that he cannot be convicted of injustice, and so he says, "Or who dares to say to him: You have done evil?" To be able to condemn someone for evil, he must be subject to a higher power.
24 Remember, that thou extol his work, of which men have sung;
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Remember that thou knowest not His work, of Whom men have sung. In Holy Scripture sometimes Angels, and sometimes persons ['homines'] of perfect life, are called 'men.' ['viri.'] For that an Angel is sometimes called a man, the Prophet Daniel bears witness, saying, Behold, the man Gabriel. [Dan.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He begins as a result to show clearly that man cannot examine the ways of God, which are his works, saying, "Remember that you are ignorant of his work about which men sang." These are the wise, whom he calls men because of the strength of their souls. He says, "they sang," because of the ancient custom of the wise who represented divine and philosophical things in verse.
25 Every son of earth, hath viewed it, Mortal man, looketh at it from afar.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 All men see Him, every one beholdeth afar off. Every man from the fact that he is created rational, ought to conclude from reason that He Who made him is God. And to see Him at this time, is doubtless to behold, through reason, His sovereign power. But when it is said, All men see Him, it is rightly subjoined, Every one beholdeth afar off.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 No matter how some wise men may be, they cannot arrive at knowing and explaining God's essence. But all the thought of man and his discourse about God is through his works. For no one lacks wisdom to such an extent that he does not perceive some of the divine works.
26 Lo, GOD, is greater than we can know, The number of his years, even past finding out!
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Behold, God is great, surpassing our knowledge. The number of His years cannot be reckoned. He had said above, Behold, God is lofty. [ver. 22] He now says again, Behold, God is great. Why is it, that when speaking of God he says, 'Behold,' and again repeats, 'Behold,' if it be not that we say, 'Behold' of that thing, which we point out as present?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 From this he concludes that God exceeds the knowledge of man in his excellence, and so he says, "Behold the great God who surpasses our science," for God cannot be known by us perfectly not because of some defect in him, as happens in motion and time, but because of his excellence.
27 For he draweth up drops of water, They trickle as rain through his mist;
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Who taketh away the stars of rain, and poureth forth showers like whirlpools. There are two kinds of just persons in this life; one, namely, of those who live uprightly, but teach nothing; another, of those who live uprightly, and teach accordingly.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He shows next the magnitude of the works of God which exceed human reason, listing different changes in the air which is sometimes disposed to dryness. Concerning this he says, "He bears the drops of rain," by preventing it from raining.
28 With which the clouds flow down, They drop on man in abundance.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Which flow from the clouds. Which cover all things above. For these whirlpools do indeed flow from the clouds; because, if the power of understanding did not begin with the holy Apostles, it would not flow more fully through the mouths of teachers. For by 'clouds' in Holy Scripture, sometimes fickle men, sometimes Prophets, sometimes Apostles, are designated.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Such an abundance of rain seems wonderful if the origin of rain is considered, because so much water bursts forth from the clouds which have no solidity, and as to this he says, "which," the torrents "flow from the clouds" not because such rain exists in act in the clouds, but because the vapors themselves of the clouds gradually condense into rain.
29 But surely none can understand the burstings of the cloud, the crashing of his pavilion!
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 If He will spread out clouds as His tent, and lighten with His light from above, He will cover also the ends of the sea. The Lord 'spreads out the clouds,' when, opening the way of preaching to His ministers, He disperses them in every direction, through the breadth of the world. But it is well said, As His tent. For a tent is wont to be pitched, on a journey.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Then he speaks about the clouds themselves saying, "If he wills to unfold the clouds like a tent," because the clouds hide heaven which is the seat of God like the seat of some man is hidden in a tent. He says, "If he wills," to show that the divine will is the principle of natural works.
30 Lo! he hath spread out over it, his lightning, The bed of the sea, hath he covered.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The lightening proceeds from the clouds because of the collision of the winds, and so he says, "and to make lightening with his light from above." Sometimes the clouds cover heaven as far as the horizon of some region and seem to enclose the farthest bounds of the sea beneath this, and so he says, "even the roots of the sea he will cover" with the tent of the clouds.
31 For, by those things, he executeth judgment on peoples, He giveth food in abundance:
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 For by these things judgeth He the people, and giveth food to many mortals. By these words of preachers, that is drops of the clouds, by these lightnings of miracles, God doubtless judges the peoples; because He invites their terrified hearts to repentance.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 To will means properly to act for an end, and so he shows the end of these works, "Through these he judges the peoples," because men are punished by them, "and he gives food to many mortal men," in the sense that the rains are useful to the fertility of the land which produces food for men.
32 Upon both hands, he putteth a covering of lightning, and layeth command upon it against an assailant:
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He hideth the light from the mighty. And ordereth it to return again. For those in truth are 'mighty,' who exalt themselves with lofty thoughts. Against whom it is said by Isaiah; Woe unto you, who are wise in your own eyes, and prudent in your own sight. [Is. 5, 21] Against whom also Paul says, Be not wise in your own conceit. [Rom.
Ishodad of Merv · AD 850 The words, "He will cover the light with his hands" [mean] that when he wants to make the rain fall for the sake of earth, he condenses the air as if with his hands and covers the sun with clouds.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Eliud had spoken above (36:27-30) about the changes in the atmosphere: drought and rain, as a result of the covering of the clouds from which God produces lightning from his light. Now he treats in an extended manner about the light itself, which is sometimes hidden by the clouds and is sometimes seen, and the thunder which arises from the clouds.
33 His rolling thunder telleth concerning him,—The cattle, even, concerning him that is coming up.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He declares of it to His friend, that it is his possession, and that he may come up to it. The friend of truth is a lover of upright conduct. Whence the Truth Itself says to Its disciples, Ye are My friends, if ye have done what I command you.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 One must remember that sensible things are a kind of sign of intelligible things, and so we come to the knowledge of intelligibles through sensible effects. Among all the sensible effects the most spiritual is light.