1 Againe the Lord answered Iob out of the whirle winde, and said,
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 The Lord added, and spake to Job; Doth he that contendeth with God, so easily remain quiet? He that reproveth God, ought certainly also to answer Him. 107. The holy man did not consider that his merits were being increased, but that his vices were being cut away by this so great severity of the scourge.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 All these things have been brought to show the greatness of divine wisdom and power which produces such marvelous effects. We understand that after Job had heard so many wonderful things about the divine effects he was stunned and silent.
2 Girde vp now thy loynes like a man: I will demaunde of thee, and declare thou vnto me.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 "Is he who asserts himself with confidence against God," who offers to argue with him, "so easily stopped?", namely, as if he has been vanquished like you who are silent? "Certainly he who accuses God," in disputing with him about his just judgments, "ought also to answer him." For it is just that one who provokes another to dispute should also be prepared to answer.
3 Wilt thou disanul my iudgement? or wilt thou condemne me, that thou mayst be iustified?
4 Or hast thou an arme like God? or doest thou thunder with a voyce like him?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 I who have spoken lightly, what can I answer? 1. The higher holy men advance with God, in the dignity of virtues, the more accurately do they discover that they are unworthy; because while they become close to the light, they find out whatever escaped their notice in themselves, and they appear to themselves the more deformed without, in proportion as that is very beautiful, wh…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Lest Job seem obstinate in his opinion even though he was proved wrong, he breaks forth in words of humility, and so the text continues, "Job answered and said to the Lord: What can I who have spoken thoughtlessly answer?" Consider here that Job, speaking in the presence of God and his own conscience is not accusing himself of speaking falsely or of a proud intention, for he ha…
5 Decke thy selfe now with maiestie and excellencie, and aray thy selfe with beautie and glory.
Desert Fathers · AD 500 At a meeting of the hermits in Cellia, Evagrius made a speech. Then the priest there said, 'Evagrius, we know that if you were in your own country, perhaps you would already be a bishop, ruling over many.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 One thing have I spoken, which I would I had not said; and another, to which I will add no further. 3. If we examine the former words of blessed Job, we find that he has said nothing wickedly. But if we distort his words, which were uttered with truth and freedom, into a sort of sin of pride, there will no longer be two only; because there will be many.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 I do penance for these things which I have said, and so he says, "I have said one thing, and would that I had not," namely, when I said that I wanted to dispute with God, (13:3) "and another thing," that I preferred my own justice when it was a question of divine judgments. (6:2) He does not acknowledge the third thing which Eliud had reproved him with, i.e.
6 Cast abroad the indignation of thy wrath, and beholde euery one that is proude, and abase him.
Origen of Alexandria · AD 253 "I will question you, and you answer me." The perfect rewards of the struggles are reserved after this life to those who fought bravely. The grace of God nevertheless offers a sort of pledge to the athletes. For this reason, Job faced the hardest fights; while losing his riches, he praised him who gave him these afflictions.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 In what he said before, the Lord demonstrated his wisdom and power by recalling the marvelous things which appear in his effects, (cc. 38 and 39) so that he might make clear that no man can contend with God either in wisdom or in power. Here he proceeds further to accuse Job for invoking his own justice, (27:6) which to some sounded like a derogation of divine justice.
7 Looke on euery one that is arrogant, and bring him lowe: and destroy the wicked in their place.
8 Hide them in the dust together, and binde their faces in a secret place.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 Either he speaks here about his present intervention, as if to say, "I do not speak so in order to condemn you but to show that you are righteous"; or he wants to speak about his trial by calling intervention his approval.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Wilt thou disannul My judgment, and condemn Me, that thou mayest be justified? 5. Whoever strives to defend himself against the scourges of God, endeavours to set aside the judgment of Him Who inflicts them. For when he says that he is not smitten for his own fault, what else does he but accuse the injustice of the Smiter?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Consider that Job in appealing to his own justice, did not intend to impute evil to the divine judgment as his three friends and Eliud wrongly understood.
9 Then will I confesse vnto thee also, that thy right hand can saue thee.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 When there is a reference to the voice or the "arm" [power] of God, we must be very careful not to attribute to him any corporeal feature. To enclose into corporeal dimensions him who cannot be circumscribed and fills and embraces everything would mean to fall into the heresy of the Anthropomorphites.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Therefore, the Lord, in accusing Job, proposes the excellence of God over men, and this excellence is indeed manifested in his effects. But since now it is a question of the comparison of justice which properly is not perceived in irrational things, to show divine excellence he considers the effects which God works in rational creatures.
10 Behold now Behemoth (whom I made with thee) which eateth grasse as an oxe.
Origen of Alexandria · AD 253 A slanderer conspired against you. Sometimes he said to me, "Stretch out your hand now." He said to me, "Touch all that he has," and he added about you that "you would have cursed me to my face." But, on the contrary, you were victorious. Therefore I say to you, "Clothe yourself with glory. Abase the slanderer completely. Humiliate his angels.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Surround thyself with beauty, and raise thyself on high, and be full of glory, and array thyself with beautiful garments. 8. Thou understandest, As I. For He surrounds Himself with beauty, of Whom it is written, The Lord hath reigned, He hath put on beauty. [Ps. 93, 1] He is raised aloft in us, when He is proved to be in His own Nature unsearchable by our minds.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 From effects of this kind he demonstrates the divine excellence as to three things. First, as to beauty when he says, "Deck yourself with beauty," as if to say: If you were as powerful in your works as God is, attribute his beauty to yourself, and so he clearly says, "Deck yourself," for God does not surround himself with beauty as something added beyond his essence but his ess…
11 Behold now, his strength is in his loynes, and his force is in the nauil of his belly.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Scatter the proud in thy wrath. 9. Thou understandest, As I, Who in the season of tranquillity bear with them united against Me, and when I come at last with severity, I scatter them in My wrath.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Then he shows the effects of divine justice which he causes in the wicked in a more extensive way. First he does this as to men.
12 When hee taketh pleasure, his taile is like a cedar: the sinews of his stones are wrapt together.
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 These words are not spoken with an offended mind but with zealous affection, so that they may be useful in consoling and instructing him and that he may understand that to perform such a great judgment is beyond human strength.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Look on all the proud, and confound them, and tread down the wicked in their place. 11. Thou understandest, As I. For the proud are confounded at the look of the Lord, either here, by His mercy, when acknowledging and condemning their faults, or there, by suffering punishments from His justice.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The first punishment common to both of these types of proud men is confusion. Since when they could not attain the height to which they pretended, they are apparently confounded by their failure, and so he says, "Consider all the proud and confound them," and he also said already, "If his pride should ascend up to heaven, he will be thrown out like dung in the end." (20:6) The…
13 His bones are like staues of brasse, and his small bones like staues of yron.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Hide them in the dust, and at the same time plunge their faces into the pit. 12. As if He said, As I. For God by a just judgment hides the proud and impious in the dust, because He permits their hearts to be overwhelmed with those earthly employments, which they choose, having scorned the love of their Creator.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The third punishment is that after they are reduced to the lowest place, the brightness of their renown ends. For it is just that those who sought the ostentation of glory should be erased from the memories of men, as Proverbs says, "The name of the wicked will rot," (10:7) and so the text continues, "You will hide them in the decay together" that is, you will make them forgott…
14 He is the chiefe of the wayes of God: he that made him, will make his sworde to approch vnto him.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 And I will confess that thy right hand can save thee. 14. As if He were openly saying, If thou art able to do these terrible things, which I Myself have displayed, I attribute to thee, and not to Myself, all the good things thou hast done.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The Lord had treated these things first as to his own proper works. It is proper to him also to not need anyone else's help, something which does not befit man as he cannot do these works, and so he says, "And I will admit that your right hand can save you," as if to say: If you can do these works just mentioned which are proper to God alone, you can reasonably attribute to you…
15 Surely the mountaines bring him foorth grasse, where all the beastes of the fielde play.
Ephrem the Syrian · AD 373 The Behemoth is a dragon, that is, a land animal, just as the Leviathan is an aquatic sea animal.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Behold Behemoth, which I made with thee. 16. Whom does He suggest, under the name 'Behemoth,' except the ancient enemy? which being interpreted from the Hebrew word, means 'Animal' in the Latin tongue. For when his malice is added below, his person is plainly pointed out.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 In the above remarks the Lord had told of the effects of his power which he works in evil men. Here he goes on the describe the evil of the devil.
16 Lyeth hee vnder the trees in the couert of the reede and fennes?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 His strength is in his loins, and his force is in the navel of his belly. 20. The places for the seed of coition are said to be in the loins with men, but in the navel with women. For hence it is that the Truth says to His disciples; Let your loins be girded about.
Ishodad of Merv · AD 850 The words "its strength is in its cover" [mean] its strength and vigor are precisely in the animal itself. Animals usually take shelter in different places, but [the author] says this animal does not need a shelter at all.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Second, he describes his conjugal relations. For the principal animal pleasures consist in food and intercourse. He describes the intercourse of the elephant first as to the principle of pleasure by which animals are excited to intercourse when he says, "His strength is in his loins," for semen is drawn to the genital members from the loins or from the kidney area.
17 Can the trees couer him with their shadow? or can the willowes of the riuer compasse him about?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He setteth fast his tail, like a cedar. 22. There are in these words many points, to be brought forward for moral instruction. But we examine in the first place the violences of this Behemoth, in order afterwards to detect more accurately his crafts.
Bonaventure · AD 1257 In the twelfth mystery, the opening of scriptures, the Antichrist is symbolized by the beast from the depth, the one that comes up out of the abyss, who will crush all things.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Animals who perform coitus of this kind press the tail between their legs when they perform the sexual act, and so he says, "He stiffens his tail like a cedar," which he says because of its great size.
18 Behold, he spoyleth the riuer, and hasteth not: he trusteth that he can draw vp Iorden into his mouth.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 His bones are as pipes of brass. His cartilage as plates of iron. 29. In the body they are bones which hold the members together, and members which are held together. This beast then has flesh, it has bones also; because there are some wicked persons, who are yet retained in error by others, and others still more wicked who retain others also in error.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Third, he describes the motion of the elephants which are said to have inflexible feet, shin bones and legs in order to sustain the weight of their body, and "they have solid bones without joints." To show this he says, "His bones are like tubes of bronze," because like tubes of bronze they cannot be bent.
19 Hee taketh it with his eyes, and thrusteth his nose through whatsoeuer meeteth him.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He is the chief of the ways of God. 47. As if He were plainly saying, He has strength sufficient for so many purposes, because in the nature of things the Creator made him first, when creating him in his substance. For what do we understand by the 'ways' of God, but His doings? Of which He says by the Prophet; For My ways are not as your ways. [Is.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The Lord explains these things which have been said figuratively continuing, "He," that is, Satan about whom these metaphors are used, "is as the first of the ways of God," of his works.
20 Canst thou drawe out Liuiathan with an hooke, and with a line which thou shalt cast downe vnto his tongue?
John Chrysostom · AD 407 "And when he has gone up to a steep mountain, he causes joy to the quadrupeds in the deep." This means the wild animals have raised their heads only when this animal has withdrawn to the mountains. If [God] has created these two enormous beasts, he did so in order that you might know that he may create all of them according to their own type.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 The mountains bring him forth grass. 1. The proud become the more familiarly devoted to the ancient enemy, who is described by the voice of the Lord, under the name Behemoth, the higher they swell with pride within, at the successes of this life.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since he had said that, "He eats grass like an ox," (v.10) he shows where he gets his grass to eat, and so he says, "The mountains yield grass for him." By this one understands that the proud and lofty men in this world offer the devil the material of his delight or eating.
21 Canst thou cast an hooke into his nose? canst thou perce his iawes with an angle?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He sleepeth under the shadow, in the covert of the reed, in moist places. 5. Overshadowing is sometimes used in Holy Scripture for the Incarnation of the Lord, or the cooling of the mind from the heat of carnal thoughts; whence by the expression 'shadow' this cooling of the heart in consequence of heavenly protection is usually spoken of.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He next describes his habitat. Consider here that Aristotle says in The History of Animals V, "Elephants stay in the wilderness and especially on the banks of rivers;" and because there are usually reeds, willows, and shady places on the banks of rivers, he therefore shows the habitat of the elephant saying, "He sleeps in the shade in a thicket of reeds in wet places." Since th…
22 Will he make many prayers vnto thee, or speake thee faire?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 The shadows cover his shadow. 10. For all the wicked are in truth shadows of the devil: for while they give themselves up to imitate his iniquity, they derive, as it were, a form of resemblance from his body. But as the reprobate are his 'shadows' in the plural number, so each separate sinner is his 'shadow' in the singular.
Ishodad of Merv · AD 850 The words "the shadows surround it." Because of the size of the animal, [the author says], anywhere it goes, it casts shadows around it. The words "the crows like a torrent surround it." [This is said] because the habit of these birds is to approach and croak anytime they see something terrifying.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since this animal does not desire just any kind of shade but deep dark shade, he says, "The shadows protect his shadow," to say that the smaller shadow is protected by the larger shadow from the heat. He shows the cause of this shade saying, "the falling willows cover him," for willows make a thicker and cooler shade than reeds.
23 Will hee make a couenant with thee? and wilt thou take him as a seruant for euer?
Cyril of Jerusalem · AD 386 Jesus sanctified Baptism by being Himself baptized. If the Son of God was baptized, what godly man is he that despiseth Baptism? But He was baptized not that He might receive remission of sins, for He was sinless; but being sinless, He was baptized, that He might give to them that are baptized a divine and excellent grace.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 He will drink up a river, and will not wonder, and trusteth that Jordan can flow into his mouth. 12. For what is in this place designated by the name of 'river,' except the downward course of the human race, which rises at its birth, as if from the source of its fountain, but passes down, as if flowing to its lowest level at its death?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 For the same reason this animal seeks humid and shady places, he also drinks a lot of water, and so Aristotle says in The History of Animals VII that, "Now an elephant drinks fourteen Macedonian measures of water as a draft and again later another eight." So to describe the great quantity of his drink he says, "He will swallow rivers and not wonder," because he is used to drink…
24 Wilt thou play with him as with a bird? or wilt thou bynd him for thy maydes? Shall the companions baket with him? shall they deuide him among the marchants? Canst thou fill the basket with his skinne? or the fishpanier with his head? Lay thine hand vpon him: remember the battel, and do no more so. Behold, his hope is in vaine: for shall not one perish euen at the sight of him?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 In his eyes He will take him as with a hook. 14. It is much to be observed, that the Lord, tempering in His mercy the words of His Scripture, alarms us at one time with sharp excitements, comforts us at another with gentle consolations, and blends terror with comforts, and comforts with terror; in order that, while they are both tempered towards us with wonderful skill of manag…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Yet there are some who are not overcome by the devil but rather obtain victory over him. This principally pertains to Christ, about whom the Apocalypse says, "Behold the lion of the tribe of Judah has conquered." (5:5) Consequently, this happens to others through the grace of Christ, as 1 Cor.