1 But Job, responding, said:
John Chrysostom · AD 407 This is what Job means, you show wisdom in the misfortunes of other people. Since you are far away from my misfortunes, you admonish me while you experience a peaceful life.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Eliphaz had clearly noted in earlier verses three things in the lament of Job: despair because he seemed to desire not to exist; impatience or immoderate sorrow because of the sighs and moans which he said he was enduring; and presumption because he asserted his innocence. The whole discourse of Eliphaz in the previous chapters was about these three things.
2 I wish that my sins, for which I deserve wrath, and the calamity that I endure, were weighed out on a balance.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Some men's minds are more tormented by scourges than reproaches, but some are more wounded by reproaches than by scourges. For oftentimes the tortures of speech assail us worse than any pains, and while they make us rise up in our vindication, they lay us low in impatience.
3 Compared to the sand of the sea, they would appear heavier, and so my words are full of sorrow.
Didymus the Blind · AD 398 Eliphaz believed that Job said all this out of desperation. Since Eliphaz's first words to Job were trustworthy—words that insisted that Job suffered because of sin—Job responds, "It seems my words are valueless and lack faith." Consequently, Job adds the reason why Eliphaz does not believe in him when he says, "For the arrows of the Almighty are in me," thus making the followi…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 But the adversity appears to be much greater and so he continues, "Like the sands on the sea," which means without parallel, "this", i.e. the calamity, "could not equal them," i.e.
4 For the arrows of the Lord are in me, my spirit drinks of their indignation, and the terrors of the Lord are soldiers against me.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 For the arrows of the Almighty are in me. For by the epithet of 'arrows' sometimes the utterances of preaching, sometimes the arrows of visitation are denoted. Now the utterances of preaching are represented by 'arrows;' for in this, that they smite men's vices, they pierce the hearts of evil doers.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He adds that there are two causes of pain. Pain is sometimes caused by things someone has already endured, sometimes by things he is afraid he will endure.
5 Will the wild ass bray when he has grass? Or will the ox bellow when he stands before a full manger?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 MORAL INTERPRETATION Doth the wild ass bray when he hath grass? Or loweth the ox over his full manger? Who else are denoted by the term of 'the wild ass,' saving they who being set in the field of faith, are not bound by the reins of any ministration?
Ishodad of Merv · AD 850 By mentioning the wild ass, the author speaks about all wild animals, and by referring to the ox, about all cattle. His point is that neither wild animals nor cattle complain when they have food to eat. Nor do humans complain when they can have at their disposal the necessary things they need and what is seasoned with salt.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The objection could be made: you certainly have cause for suffering, but you should not burst out in words of pain from it. Against this objection Job responds using examples which are found in other animals. For man is like other animals in sensitive nature, and so those things which sensitive nature naturally entails must be present in man, as in the other animals.
6 Or can one eat bland food, which is not seasoned with salt? Or can anyone taste that which, if tasted, causes death?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Can that which is unsavoury be eaten without salt? And because this same Law, before the coming of our Mediator, was held not in a spiritual but in a carnal manner, it is rightly added, Can that which is unsavoury be eaten without salt? In the Law, the virtue of the hidden meaning is the salt of the letter.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 On the other hand, someone might concede that it is natural to express pain vocally conceived, but as the Stoics thought, it does not pertain to the wise man to conceive sadness in his heart for any reason whatsoever. Job demonstrates this to be against sensitive nature. For sense cannot but be repulsed by the unsuitable and the harmful.
7 The things that my soul was unwilling to touch before, now, because of anguish, are my foods.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 Sores and pus were not enough. A new affliction is added. Job's disease has destroyed his entire sensitivity to the extent that even his nourishment has become a torture for him. Indeed, Job says, the nauseating smell of gangrene has deprived him of the capability to distinguish sensations. Is there anything more painful than that torment?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 The things which my soul refused to touch are for straitness become my meat. And hence in the voice of the Church it is immediately added by the Prophetic Spirit, The things which my soul refused to touch are for straitness become my meat. For he goes very far wrong, who imagines that the words of blessed Job were delivered with an eye to the historical fact alone.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 But though it is true the wise man suffers sadness, nevertheless his reason is not absorbed by this sadness. Job shows as a consequence that although he himself might suffer sadness, he still had the greatest concern and caution to protect himself against sadness, so as not to be led by sadness to do something evil. To avoid this, he preferred death.
8 Who will grant that my petition may arrive and that God may bestow on me what I expect,
Didymus the Blind · AD 398 He who asks to be wounded does not pray out of exhaustion that his prayer might be granted but in order to fulfill his task. This task was to fulfill the right deeds or to make visible to the friends for their benefit the reason for the hardships, [namely,] that they had been imposed as a test. Then they would not make mistakes against the righteous.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Oh that I might have my request, and that God would grant me the thing that I long for! Even that He That hath begun would destroy me. Let him let loose His hand, and cut me off! Let this be my comfort; that He should afflict me with sorrow, and not spare.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He shows this same thing when he says, "Who will grant that my prayer find fulfillment?" He shows that this prayer is made not only with the lips, but also from the bottom of his heart when he continues, "may God grant me my hope!" He expresses the content of the prayer saying, "May he who began this," i.e. to afflict me, "destroy me," in death.
9 and that he who, at first, had crushed me, will let loose his hand and cut me down?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 That He That hath begun would bruise me! For very often the Lord begins to work in us the bruising of our vicious habits, but when the mind is lifted up at the very first step of its progress, and when it already exalts itself as on the ground of its virtuous attainments, it opens an entrance to the adversary, that rages against it, who penetrating into the depths of the heart,…
Ishodad of Merv · AD 850 "He would let loose his hand and finish me!" That is, may he put an end to my life by his intervention. Again Job speaks, "I would be finished again with violence and no mercy." In a word, "I desire that God inflict death on me violently and mercilessly.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He expresses the content of the prayer saying, "May he who began this," i.e. to afflict me, "destroy me," in death. He continues, "May he free his hand and cut me down." The hand of God expresses the divine power by which God has afflicted him, and God binds his hand in a way from his mercy and by his will when he does not afflict him.
10 And may this be my consolation, that in afflicting me with sorrow, although he might not be lenient with me, I still do not contradict the words of the Holy One.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 "I do not care to oppose your words," Job says. "It seems to me, in fact, that I have committed nothing resembling what you say. I don't state this openly. I simply say that I am suffering punishments that go beyond what human nature can endure.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 And let this be my consolation, that afflicting me with pain He spare not. The Elect, when they know that they have done unlawful things, but find upon careful examination that they have met with no afflictions in return for those unlawful deeds, with the immense force of their fear, are in a ferment with alarm, and labour and travail with dark misgivings, lest grace should hav…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Since he said that the things he did not formerly want to touch had now become his food, he shows this must be understood to mean that death which was abhorrent to him, has now become something pleasant. So he continues, "This thought, at least, may give me comfort: that in afflicting me with pain, he will not spare me," i.e.
11 For what is my strength, that I may continue? Or what is my goal, so that I may act patiently?
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 What is my strength, that I should hold up? And what is mine end that I should deal patiently? It is necessary to bear in mind, that the 'strength' of the righteous is of one sort, and the strength of the reprobate of another.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Next he gives the reason from his frailty that he would be led to contradict the decrees of the Holy One. Fear of this kind can be overcome by two causes. First, if the strength of reason is so great in itself that it could not be overcome in any way. This is the case in those whose free will has been confirmed in grace. But he did not feel this kind of strength in himself.
12 My strength is not the strength of stones, nor is my flesh made of bronze.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Neither is my strength the strength of stones, nor is my flesh of brass? For what have we here denoted by 'brass' and 'stones' save the hearts of the insensate, who oftentimes even receive the strokes of the Most High, and yet they are not softened by any strokes of discipline?
Bonaventure · AD 1257 The third middle way is fortitude, which is concerned with fears and acts of valor. A man needs it in order to be neither fainthearted nor rash, but that he be able to bear frightful trials and even death. For some men do fall into cowardice and faintheartedness.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 To explain this he says, "My strength is not the strength of a stone." For a stone experiences strength without experiencing feeling, but a man experiences strength along with the emotional experience of harmful things. So he continues, "nor is my flesh bronze", i.e.
13 Behold, there is no help for me in myself, and my loved ones also have withdrawn from me.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Lo, there is no help to me in myself. It is now made clear to whom the mind of the stricken man had recourse for hope, seeing that he declares that there was no hope to him in himself; but because he intimates that in himself he was weak, for the earning of yet greater strength, let him add how he was even forsaken by his neighbours, My friends also departed from me.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Job had shown in the preceding verses that he felt pain and spoke words from his pain in conformity with reason, but yet he was not carried away by his pain in the things which he suffered.
14 He who takes away mercy from his friend, abandons the fear of the Lord.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Whoso taketh away pity from his friend, forsaketh the fear of the Lord. Who else is here denoted by the name of a friend, saving every neighbour, who is united to us in a faithful attachment in proportion as, having received from us good service in this present time, he effectually aids us toward attaining hereafter the eternal country?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 To show they are blameworthy for this, he continues, "He takes away mercy from a neighbor," namely in the time of sorrow, "forsakes the fear of the Lord," that is, the reverence due to God, because of whom and in whom one loves his neighbor. As John says, "Whoever does not love his brother whom he does see, how can he love the God whom he cannot see?" (1 John 4:20)
15 My brethren have disregarded me, like a torrent that passes swiftly through the steep valleys.
Ephrem the Syrian · AD 373 The streams' waters fall from heaven and are symbols of the prophecies and oracles announced to the Jewish people through the prophets, just as through mystic clouds, as if the prophets' words were rains falling from heaven.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 My brethren have passed by me like a brook which passeth by rapidly in the hollows. Because the mind of the reprobate is set on present things alone, for the most part it proves a stranger to the scourge now, in proportion as hereafter it remains an exile from the inheritance.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Next he shows his family has abandoned him when he says, "My brothers," i.e. my relatives, "have passed me by." He uses the analogy of those who walk along together. If one falls in a ditch, the others pass by nevertheless abandoning him there.
16 Those who fear frost, snow will rush over them.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 JOB MEANS TO SAY THIS: there is no memory or trace left of my former prosperity. And that is even worse than my misfortune itself. "Oh, that one would indeed weigh the wrath that is upon me and take up my sorrow in a balance together!" And Job now tries to describe his sorrows. "I perceive my food to be loathsome [as the smell of a lion]." I wish to die, but I do not die.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Over those that fear the frost, the snow rushes down. For the frost congeals below, but the snow falls down from above. And often there are persons, who, while they fear temporal adversities, expose themselves to the severity of everlasting visitation. Concerning whom it is rightly declared by the Psalmist, There were they in great fear where no fear was.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 That they might not believe they did this with impunity, he adds, "Those who fear frost will be covered by snow," as if to say: He who fails in justice and mercy because of fear for a lesser danger, exposes himself to still greater dangers.
17 At that time, when they are scattered, they will perish, and when it becomes hot, they will be freed from their place.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 What time they be dissipated they shall perish. For all persons that are ruled by concern for the present life, are brought to nought by the loss of it, and then they are undone without, who have for long been undone within by disregarding the things of eternity. Concerning whom it is rightly added, When they have become hot, they shall be dissolved from their place.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 "And they will vanish from their place as though dried up." He uses the metaphor of snow, which he has already mentioned, for it does not immediately melt with the first heat when it is very hard and frozen, but when not yet frozen, it melts immediately when touched by the rays of the sun and becomes slush.
18 The paths of their steps are entangled; they will walk in vain and will perish.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 The paths of their steps are involved. All that is involved is folded back into itself. And there are some who as it were resolve, with all the purpose of their heart, to resist the vicious habits that mislead them, but when the crisis of the temptation comes full upon them, they do not hold out in their purposed resolution.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He shows the cause of this when he continues, "The paths they follow are tangled up." What is entangled goes back on itself with a kind of twist and turn, and so the footpaths of those men are entangled who seek nothing in their kinsmen and friends except their own advantage. Because of this they simulate friendship in time of prosperity but they pass by in time of adversity.
19 Consider the paths of Thema, the ways of Saba, and wait a little while.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Consider the paths of Tema, the ways of Sheba, and wait a little while. But we are more effectually withheld from imitating the wicked, if we calculate their losses by the end. Whence it is well added even with a charge, Consider the paths of Tema, the ways of Sheba, and wait a little while.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Therefore, he did not have support in himself, in his servants or in his relatives. As a further consequence, he demonstrates that he did not have help from his other friends saying, "Look for the paths to Teman, the roads to Saba," lands where he seemed to have had his greatest friends, for even Eliphaz had come from Teman.
20 They have been thrown into confusion, just as I had hoped; they have even come to me and are overwhelmed with shame.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 They are confounded, because I have hoped. But blessed Job, after he had brought in the shortness of the present life in terms of contempt, therefore in the voice of all the Elect rises up justly against the wicked, subjoining, They are confounded, because I have hoped.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 You will not see this because, "They are embarrassed," to come to me; "because I hoped for them" i.e. because there was a time when I should have hoped for help from them. This is because men who do not want to help someone are ashamed to visit them if they think they will ask them for help reasonably.
21 Now you have arrived, and merely by seeing my affliction, you are afraid.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 For now ye are come, to see my stroke, and are afraid. As though he said in plain words, 'I feared God then, when, buoyed up with prosperity, I felt no hurts of the scourge. But ye, who fear not God from love, dread Him from the stroke of the rod alone.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 It is not surprising for others to refuse to help me since even you, who seem wiser, fail to do it. So he continues, "Now you have come to see me and in only seeing my disease, you are afraid," but perhaps you feel obliged to help me. But do not be afraid, because I have not asked you for help in anything, nor do I even request you to assist me with money.
22 Did I say: “Bring to me and give to me from your necessities?”
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 MORAL INTERPRETATION Did I say, Bring unto me? or, Give me of your substance? or, Deliver me from the enemy's hand? or, Redeem me from the hand of the mighty?
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 It is not surprising for others to refuse to help me since even you, who seem wiser, fail to do it. So he continues, "Now you have come to see me and in only seeing my disease, you are afraid," but perhaps you feel obliged to help me. But do not be afraid, because I haven't asked you for help in anything, nor do I even request you to assist me with money.
23 or, “Free me from the hand of the enemy and rescue me from the hand of the strong?”
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 So he continues, "Now you have come to see me and in only seeing my disease, you are afraid," but perhaps you feel obliged to help me. But do not be afraid, because I haven't asked you for help in anything, nor do I even request you to assist me with money.
24 Teach me, and I will be silent, and if by chance I have been ignorant of anything, instruct me.
John Chrysostom · AD 407 However, even in such a condition, Job does not refuse to learn. "You may say something useful. I will be silent, if you speak helpful words." But they could not, to be sure, present evidence, but simply proceeded through conjectures. And since Job's life was manifestly full of virtue, they supposed that it was not the ground of his punishments.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Teach me, and I will hold my tongue, and cause me to understand wherein I have erred. It seems doubtful under the scale of what pointing this should hang, whether it be joined to what he had brought in, Did I say, or whether the sentence is spoken disjoined from the preceding, so that it is said thereby in reproach, Teach me, and I will hold my tongue, and cause me to understan…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Nor has he sought the help of instruction from them. So this is the meaning of: Have I said to you: "Teach me?" in speculative matters, "and I will say no more, and if perhaps I have been ignorant: Instruct me?" in practical actions.
25 Why have you diminished the words of truth, when there is none of you who is able to offer proof against me?
Olympiodorus of Alexandria · AD 600 Job's words mean … "It is likely you have suffered the same in many things." Truth, however, is always hateful to many. Therefore, you despise my words of truth. "You do not come down to me," Job says, "nor do you speak about the gifts of grace like people who desire to encourage. On the contrary, you accuse me openly, whereas I have never accused you.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Wherefore have ye detracted from the words of truth; when there is none of you that is able to convict them? He must himself be pure from evil, who makes it his concern to correct the evil practices of other men, so as not to be taken up with earthly imaginations, not to give way to grovelling desires, in order that he may the more clearly see what things others ought to avoid,…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 Not only do they offer him no help, but they even afflict him further with their words as much as they can. So he adds, "Why do you slander true ideas?" which he spoke first in his lamentation and which Eliphaz seemed to reprove as has been said. He disproves all the reasons which can excuse a detractor to justify his conduct to show this detraction is inexcusable.
26 You prepare speeches as so much noise, and you offer words into the wind.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Ye only set in order speeches to upbraid, and ye speak words against the wind. There are two sorts of speech, which are very troublesome and mischievous to mankind, the one which aims to commend even froward things, the other which studies to be always carping even at right ones.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 "You join fine words together," since you carefully compose them so that your words may not seem lightly spoken. The third is when someone strengthens the arguments he uses against someone else with efficacious reasons. He excludes this saying, "You cast your words to the wind," as if to say: Your words are empty for they do not have the support of reason.
27 You encroach upon the orphan, and you strive to undermine your friend.
Hesychius of Jerusalem · AD 450 "You would even attack the orphan," that is, me, for I am deprived of any human assistance. And since God is "the Father of the orphans," you make him angry by offending me. "And you would trample your friend underfoot" with your words. You trample him even more violently than with your feet, and you scorn the laws of friendship. But God takes these faults into account.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Yea ye overwhelm the fatherless, and ye strive to overthrow your friend. For he shews what great weakness he considers himself to be of, who calls himself 'fatherless.' But because charity even when wounded cannot quit love, he at once complains that they would have him overthrown, and yet witnesses that he is their friend.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The fourth is when someone censures someone in that time and in a state when it can be pursued he will become better and not worse as a result. But if someone wants to censure another when he is perplexed in soul and is disposed to anger, he does not seem to want his amendment so much but his ruin.
28 Such is true, so finish what you have begun. Listen closely, and see if I lie.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 But fulfil what ye have begun; give ear, and see if I lie. For because he does not fear to endure adversities, let him say, But fulfil what ye have begun; and because he does not withhold the announcements of the Truth from his very persecutors themselves, let him add, Give ear, and see if I lie.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He continues lest anyone think that he says this because he is afraid to argue with them because he could not be confident in the truth of his opinion and the justice of his case, "Despite this, finish what you began to say," so that the truth can come to light from mutual debate. So he goes on, "Lend an ear," i.e. listen, "and see," i.e.
29 Respond, I beg you, without contention, and, speaking what is just, pass judgment.
Julian of Eclanum · AD 455 While convincing his friends that they are not acting friendly but speaking against common sense, Job now tries to show that he cannot appropriately be accused of speaking harshly or of desiring death by just judges.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 Answer, I pray you, without strife. For neither do heretics try to attain truth by their investigations, but to appear to be the winners; and whereas they desire to shew for wise without, they are bound within in their foolishness with the chains of their own pride; hence it comes to pass that they look out for contests of rivalry, and concerning God, Who is our Peace, they kno…
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 He continues lest anyone think that he says this because he is afraid to argue with them because he could not be confident in the truth of his opinion and the justice of his case, "Despite this, finish what you began to say," so that the truth can come to light from mutual debate. So he goes on, "Lend an ear," i.e. listen, "and see," i.e.
30 And you will not find iniquity on my tongue, nor will foolishness resound in my throat.
Gregory the Dialogist · AD 604 And ye shall not find iniquity in my tongue, nor shall foolishness sound through my jaws. As if it were expressed in plain words, 'The more exactly ye weigh your own words, the more truly ye estimate those of others, and when what ye say begins to be right, ye will recognise what ye hear to be just.
Thomas Aquinas · AD 1274 The third impediment exists when someone in a disputation does not aim at the truth but at victory or glory, as happens in law cases or sophistical debates. "In speaking, judge what is right," i.e. to concede what seems to be true to you, and deny those things which seem false. "And" if you do this, "You will find no evil on my tongue," i.e.