15. (Vers. 10.). First, regarding the perversity of the Jewish people with respect to the lawgiver Moses he says: And at the time of the vintage he sent a servant to the tenants, that they should give him of the fruit of the vineyard: The Gloss says: "The first servant who is sent is Moses the lawgiver, who for forty years sought from the tenants the fruit of the Law which he had given"; the Psalm: "He sent Moses his servant, Aaron whom he chose." Concerning this sending, Exodus 3: "Come, I will send you to Pharaoh, that you may bring forth my people, the children of Israel, out of Egypt." But because the perversity of the Jews did not accept this servant, he therefore adds: Who beat him and sent him away empty. The Gloss says: "They send him away beaten and empty, because they provoked Moses in the camp, Aaron the holy one of the Lord; and again: Moses was troubled on their account, because they embittered his spirit ." Whence Deuteronomy 31: "I know your contention and your most stiff neck. While I am yet alive and going in with you, you have always acted contentiously against the Lord; how much more when I shall be dead?" Now this was done by the tenants especially, that is, the leaders of the synagogue: Numbers 16: "Behold, Korah the son of Izhar, and Dathan and Abiram rose up against Moses, and also other children of Israel, two hundred and fifty men, leaders of the synagogue, who at the time of the council were called by name." And the lesser ones followed these; whence it also follows after that "the whole multitude of the children of Israel murmured the next day against Moses and Aaron. And when sedition arose and the tumult increased, Moses and Aaron fled to the tabernacle of the covenant."
16. (Vers. 11.). Second, regarding the perversity with respect to King David, the chief worshiper of God, he adds: And he proceeded to send another servant; The Gloss says: "The other servant is David the prophet, who after Moses invited the tenants of the vineyard to the exercise of good works by the melody of psalmody and the sweetness of the harp." The Lord sent him when he chose him from the pastures to rule and feed his people, according to what the prophet David himself says in the Psalm: "He chose David his servant and took him from the sheepfolds. From following the ewes with young he took him, to shepherd Jacob his servant and Israel his inheritance." Whence 2 Kings 7: "Thus shall you say to my servant David: I took you from the pastures, following the flocks, that you should be the leader over my people Israel; and I was with you in all things, wherever you went, and I made you a great name, like the name of the great ones who are on the earth." Whence also to him, namely David, he gave a royal throne forever; to the same he gave the spirit of prophecy; to the same he gave the song of psalmody, so that he might thus incline that stubborn people.
And yet he could not soften the hardness of the Jews, on account of which he adds: But they, beating this one also and treating him with contempt, sent him away empty, because they despised his governance and leadership. Whence the Gloss: "They send him away empty, treated with contempt, saying: What portion have we in David, or what inheritance in the son of Jesse ?" Second Kings twenty. Where it is also set forth beforehand how they pursued David with Absalom: Second Kings fifteen; "A messenger came to David saying: With all their heart all Israel follows Absalom. And David said to his servants: Arise, let us flee; there will be no escape for us from the face of Absalom." And afterward in the sixteenth chapter it is said concerning the insults inflicted upon him: "Thus Shimei spoke, when he cursed the king: Go out, go out, man of blood and man of Belial! The Lord has repaid upon you all the blood of the house of Saul: and behold, evils press upon you, because you are a man of blood."
17. (Verse 12.). Third, as regards the perversity of that people with respect to the prophetic company, there is subjoined: And he added to send a third. The Gloss: "The third servant is the choir of the Prophets, who rebuked the people and foretold the evils that threatened the vineyard." Concerning the sending of this servant it is said in Jeremiah seven: "I sent to you all my servants the Prophets daily, rising early and sending. And they did not listen to me nor incline their ear, but they hardened their neck and acted worse than their fathers."
Whence he also adds: Who also cast him out, having wounded him. For they sawed Isaiah asunder, stoned Jeremiah, and reviled Ezekiel. Therefore Matthew twenty-three: "Jerusalem, Jerusalem, who killest the Prophets and stonest those who are sent to thee"; and in Acts seven Stephen said to the Jews: "Ye stiff-necked and uncircumcised in hearts and ears, ye always resist the Holy Spirit; as your fathers did, so do ye also. Which of the Prophets did your fathers not persecute? And they slew those who foretold the coming of the Just One." Therefore the Prophets themselves, seeing their hardness, both rebuked and lamented. For it is said in Isaiah five concerning the vineyard: "I expected that it would bring forth grapes, and it brought forth wild grapes"; and Jeremiah two: "How art thou turned unto me into that which is depraved, O strange vine"? and Ezekiel nineteen: "Thy mother is like a vine in thy blood, planted by the water." "And she was plucked up in wrath, cast down to the ground, and the burning wind dried up her fruit." In this, however, the astonishing faithlessness of the Jews is apparent, because all those whom they persecuted loved them most greatly. For Moses did not cease to pray for the people; Exodus thirty-two: "Why, O Lord, doth thy fury burn against thy people, whom thou hast brought forth out of Egypt?" "Either forgive them this trespass" etc. Likewise also David: "O Lord God of hosts, turn again: look down from heaven and see and visit this vine." Likewise the chorus of the Prophets, whence Jeremiah eighteen: "Remember that I stood in thy sight to speak good for them and to turn away the wrath of thine indignation from them." And all these bore the figure of Christ, of whom Isaiah fifty-three says: "He himself bore the sins of many and made intercession for transgressors."
18. (Verse 13.). But the lord of the vineyard said etc. After having described the perversity of the Jews before the coming of Christ against the persons of the servants, here he describes the malignity of their perversity after the coming, against the very Son of God, Jesus Christ. Concerning the description of this, three things are introduced, namely the gratuitous benefit of God, the perverse design of the Jews, and their flagitious deed.
First, as regards the gratuitous benefit of God, he sets forth: But the lord of the vineyard said: What shall I do? I will send my beloved son, this was the greatest benefit, according to that passage of First John four: "In this appeared the charity of God in us, that God sent his only-begotten Son into the world, that we might live through him"; and John three: "God so loved the world that he gave his only-begotten Son." This sending, moreover, was from the hidden and most secret purpose and counsel of God.
And because he had proposed this by a definite counsel, therefore he says: What shall I do? On account of which Moses in Exodus 4 was saying: "I beseech you, Lord, send him whom you are going to send"; but the Lord reserved sending him until the end, both on account of the consummation of the order, according to that passage in Galatians 4: "When we were little ones, we were serving under the elements of the world. But when the fullness of time came, God sent his Son"; and also so that it might appear that through no other could human perfidy and hardness of heart be remedied.
On account of which he adds: Perhaps, when they see him, they will reverence him. Perhaps does not denote doubt in God, who most certainly foresees all things, but the freedom of the will, which is turnable to either side. Whence the Gloss: "That he is uncertain, that is, uses a word of doubt, is not from God's ignorance, but so that free will might be preserved to man." Whence that the Jews did not reverence Christ was not a defect on God's part, but on the part of the hardness of the human heart: Isaiah 5: "What is there that I ought to have done more for my vineyard and did not do?" For those who do not reverence the Son of God will never again reverence God nor his messenger, because, John 5, "The Father has given all judgment to the Son, that all may honor the Son, just as they honor the Father; he who does not honor the Son does not honor the Father, who sent him."
19. (Verse 14.) Second, with respect to the perverse design, it is added: When the tenants saw him, they deliberated among themselves, saying: This is the heir, by a conjecture of the truth: for they did not know with certain knowledge, as is said in 1 Corinthians 2: "Which none of the princes of this world knew. For if they had known, they would never have crucified the Lord of glory." Yet they knew, even if not through faith, through certain signs leading to the belief that he was the Messiah promised in the Law. Therefore they conspired against Christ not from ignorance but from deliberate malice. Whence the Gloss says: "He openly proves that the Jews crucified the Son of God not through ignorance but through envy. For they understood that he was the one to whom it was said: Ask of me, and I will give you the nations for your inheritance." What is therefore said in Acts 3: "Now I know, brethren, that you acted through ignorance, as did also your rulers," does not exclude from the Jews all knowledge, but certain knowledge: or it is said with respect to the lesser ones, who sinned from ignorance. For the greater ones did this from deliberate malice, because they feared losing their temporal glory. Therefore he adds: Let us kill him, that the inheritance may be ours, through a machination of perversity: which they said not to acquire a new inheritance, since Christ was utterly poor, but to preserve what they already had. Whence John 11: "The chief priests and Pharisees gathered a council, saying: Because this man works many signs. If we let him go on like this, all will believe in him, and the Romans will come and take away our place and our nation." Whence that wicked design drew its origin from avarice, and it also drew its rise from envy: whence Wisdom 2: "Let us lie in wait for the just man, because he is contrary to our works and reproaches us with sins against the law and defames us with sins against our training"; and below: "Let us condemn him to a most shameful death. These things they thought and were mistaken, for their own malice blinded them"; since "by the envy of the devil, death entered into the world." A figure of this preceded in Joseph; Genesis 37: "His brothers devised to kill him and spoke to one another, saying: Behold, the dreamer comes; come, let us kill him and cast him into an old pit, and we shall say: A most wicked beast devoured him," etc.
Therefore this Gospel is read together with the history of Joseph as the Passion approaches.
20. (Vers. 15.). Third, as regards the flagitious deed, it is added: And having cast him out of the vineyard, they killed him, that is, outside Jerusalem, because it is said in the last chapter of Hebrews: "Christ suffered outside the gate. Let us therefore go forth to him outside the camp, bearing his reproach." They killed him, moreover, when they handed him over to Pilate to be killed and demanded that he be crucified; whence Acts 3: "You handed over and denied Jesus, the Son of God, before the face of Pilate, when he judged that he should be released. But you asked that a murderer be granted to you, while the Author of life you killed." And thus was fulfilled that passage of Isaiah 5 concerning the planted vineyard: "I waited for it to produce judgment, and behold, iniquity; and justice, and behold, a cry"; a cry, namely, for the killing of Christ, concerning which Mark 15: "They cried out: Crucify him! But Pilate said to them: What evil then has he done? But they cried out all the more: Crucify him!" Whence from this vineyard there came forth not wine but gall, according to that passage of Deuteronomy 32: "Their vine is of the vine of Sodom and of the suburbs of Gomorrah; their grape is a grape of gall, and their clusters most bitter. Their wine is the poison of dragons and the incurable venom of asps."
21. (Vers. 15. 16.). What therefore will he do to them etc. After he has described parabolically the benignity of divine generosity and the perversity of Jewish malice, here now in the third place he describes the severity of judicial vengeance. Concerning which three things are indicated, namely: the severity of divine vengeance, the incredulity of Jewish rebellion, and the firmness of the attestation of Scripture.
First, therefore, as regards the severity of divine vengeance, he says: What therefore will the lord of the vineyard do to them? He asks this not as one doubting, but to arouse understanding of the sentence, with respect to which he adds: He will come and destroy those tenants and give the vineyard to others; in which is given the sentence of the reprobation of the Jews and the election of the Gentiles; and this under the figure of the vineyard and the vinedressers, concerning which Isaiah 5: "Now I will show you what I will do to my vineyard: I will take away its hedge, and it shall be for plundering; I will break down its wall, and it shall be for trampling. And I will make it desolate; it shall not be pruned nor dug, and briers and thorns shall grow up over it; and I will command the clouds not to rain upon it." This reprobation the Prophet laments in the Psalm, saying: "Why have you destroyed its wall, and all who pass by the way pluck its grapes? The boar from the forest has laid it waste, and the solitary wild beast has devoured it." Concerning the election truly of the Gentiles, it is said in Romans 11: "Blindness in part has befallen Israel, so that the fullness of the Gentiles might enter in"; and concerning this, Romans 9: "I will call not-my-people my people, and her who has not obtained mercy, one who has obtained mercy"; which is taken from Hosea 2. And concerning this, Matthew 21: "The kingdom of God shall be taken from you and given to a nation producing its fruits."
22. Second, regarding the incredulity of Jewish rebellion, he adds: When they heard this, they said: God forbid, as if to say: it will not happen as you have said. But the contrary of this appears in Matthew twenty-one, where it is said thus: "When the lord of the vineyard comes, what will he do to those husbandmen? They say to him: He will miserably destroy those wicked men and will let out his vineyard to other husbandmen, who will render him the fruit in their seasons." Here, however, it is said that they contradicted. — But Augustine resolves this apparent contradiction in the book On the Harmony of the Evangelists, where he says thus: "We understand that some responded as Matthew records, and others as Luke records." — Chrysostom responds differently, saying that "they said one thing in their heart, namely what Matthew says; another with their mouth, namely what Luke says. Hence their conscience was in agreement with the divine sentence and the parable, but their tongue was contrary." Hence the Gloss: "They contradict the sentence which they recognize was spoken against their own perfidy; for they understood that what they bore in their mind was contained in the parable." And from this the wondrous judgment of God appears, because by contradicting they wished to conceal themselves, and yet they were exposing themselves, while they set themselves against the truth, contrary to that passage in Sirach four: "Do not contradict the word of truth in any way, and concerning the lie," etc.
23. (Verse 17). Third, regarding the firmness of the attestation of Scripture, he adds: But he, looking upon them, said: What then is this that is written: The stone which the builders rejected, the same has become the head of the corner? This is written in the Psalm, where it is immediately added: "This is the Lord's doing," etc. In this, moreover, is shown the wondrous humility of Christ, who willed to be rejected; on account of which Isaiah marvels in the fifty-third chapter: Lord, "who has believed our report? And the arm of the Lord, to whom has it been revealed? And he shall grow up as a tender plant before him and as a root out of a thirsty ground." "And we esteemed him as a leper and as struck by God and humiliated." In this also is shown the wondrous power of Christ, because he brought things most widely separated back to unity, as a cornerstone.
Now Christ is called a stone on account of the permanence of stability, concerning which Daniel 2: "After these things you watched, until a stone was cut from the mountain without hands and struck the statue." "But the stone that had struck the statue became a great mountain and filled the whole earth." - Now He is called angular on account of the power of connection; Ephesians 2: "He Himself is our peace, who made both one, breaking down the middle wall of partition"; "that He might create the two in Himself into one new man, making peace." Concerning this, Job 38: "Where were you when I was laying the foundations of the earth? Who set its measurements, or who laid its cornerstone?" This cornerstone of the earth is the unifying stone of the Church, concerning which Isaiah 28: "Behold, I will lay in the foundations of Zion a stone, a tested stone, a cornerstone, precious, founded in the foundation." - He is also called the head of the corner on account of the summit of perfection; Ephesians 2: "Christ Himself being the chief cornerstone, in whom the whole building, being fitted together, grows into a holy temple in the Lord," etc. And therefore First Peter 2: "Coming to whom, a living stone, rejected indeed by men." "And you yourselves as living stones," etc. - Christ is therefore to be imagined as the central stone in the whole body of the Church, which is compared to the circumference of a circle; to whom indeed all lines drawn form an angle and are united in Him as in a point of indivisibility, in which occurs the kiss of the lines of the cross converging in their midst into one. Therefore this stone is the one stabilizing the elect, and conversely is the one crushing adversaries and the reprobate.
24. (Verse 18). And therefore he adds: Everyone who falls upon that stone shall be broken, through the corruption of sin; but upon whomever it shall fall, it will grind him to powder , through the vengeance of the future judgment. For fault renders nature weak, but eternal punishment utterly crushes and reduces to dust. Whence the Gloss: "He who now despises and inflicts injuries does not yet entirely perish, but is shaken, so that he does not walk upright; but the stone shall fall upon him, which coming in judgment will crush him." Against this stone, therefore, they stumble who do not believe in him or do not imitate him: First Peter 2, "To you is the honor who believe, but to those who do not believe, the stone which the builders rejected, this has become the head of the corner, and a stone of stumbling and a rock of scandal to those who stumble at the word and do not believe, unto which also they are appointed." And so it happened to the Jews, according to that passage of Isaiah 8: "The Lord shall be to you for a sanctification, but for a stone of stumbling and a rock of scandal to the two houses of Israel, for a snare and a ruin to the inhabitants of Jerusalem. And very many of them shall stumble and fall and be broken and be ensnared and be taken. I will wait for the Lord, who has hidden his face from the house of Jacob." Those therefore who are scandalized by this stone fall, but those who are condemned by this stone are crushed, according to that passage of Isaiah 30, "Suddenly, when it is not expected, its destruction shall come, and it shall be broken as the bottle of a potter is broken with an exceedingly mighty breaking, and there shall not be found among its fragments a shard in which a little fire may be carried from the hearth, or a little water drawn from the cistern." On account of which, "not so the wicked, not so, but as the dust which the wind casts from the face of the earth."
In this authority, therefore, the Lord confirms the intention of the parable, namely that he himself is to be rejected by the Jews, that he will choose the Gentiles, that he will cast out the Jews on account of their perfidy, and that he will finally condemn them by definitive sentence.
25. (Verse 19). And the chief priests sought etc. After the refuted calumny and the exposed perfidy, there follows here the third part, in which he detects their contrived cunning. Of this cunning, the Evangelist first describes the deceitful contrivance; and second, the truthful confutation, at the passage: But considering their deceit etc.
The contrivance of cunning, however, the Evangelist describes with respect to three things, namely with respect to the Pharisees' malevolent indignation, malicious scheming, and spiteful questioning.
First therefore, as regards the malevolent indignation of the Pharisees, he says: And the chief priests and the scribes sought to lay hands on him that hour: they sought, I say, to kill him, according to that passage of John 7: "Why do you seek to kill me, a man who has spoken the truth to you?" Out of indignation of spirit, therefore, they sought, but out of fear of the people they did not dare. — Whence he adds: And they feared the people, not God; against which Proverbs 29: "He who fears man shall quickly fall." But they feared the people more than God, because they loved the praise of the people more than the truth of Christ: for the praise of the people anointed them, but the truth of Christ reproved them. — Whence it is added: For they knew that he had spoken this parable against them. And thus the truth begot hatred, and that saying of Amos 5 was verified: "They hated him who reproves in the gate, and they abominated him who speaks perfectly." As a figure of this, it is said in Jeremiah 26: "The priests and the prophets spoke to the princes and to all the people, saying: The judgment of death is upon this man, because he has prophesied against this city, as you have heard with your ears." But these Pharisees, while they wished to kill Christ, by opposing the truth they had heard were fulfilling that very truth, according to that passage of Acts 13: "Those who dwelt in Jerusalem and their rulers, not knowing this Jesus and the voices of the prophets which are read every Sabbath, fulfilled them by judging him; and finding no cause of death in him, they asked Pilate that they might kill him. And when they had fulfilled all things that were written of him, taking him down from the tree, they laid him in a tomb."
26. (Vers. 20.). Second, as regards the malicious plotting, he adds: And watching, they sent spies who feigned themselves to be just, against that passage of Proverbs 24: "Do not lie in wait and seek iniquity against the house of the just, and do not lay waste his rest." But plots are carried out through pretenses: against whom Job 36: "Dissemblers and the crafty provoke the wrath of God"; because, Proverbs 11, "the dissembler deceives his friend with his mouth."
And because dissembling has a perverse intention joined to it, therefore he adds: That they might catch him in his speech and deliver him to the principality and power of the governor, namely of Herod. Whence in Mark 12 it is said: "They send to him certain of the Pharisees and of the Herodians, that they might catch him in his word." And this was a great cunning: whence the Gloss: "What they cannot do by themselves on account of fear of the people, they wish to accomplish by the hands of the governor, so that they might appear as though innocent of his death." Therefore in the person of such men it is said in Wisdom 2: "Let us lie in wait for the just one, for he is useless to us and contrary to our works, and he reproaches us with sins against the law and defames us with sins against our training." Whence also as a figure of this, the Philistines said to Delilah in Judges 16: "Deceive him and learn from him wherein he has such great strength, and how we may be able to overcome him."
27. (Vers. 21.). Third, regarding the malicious interrogation, he adds: And they asked him, saying: Master, we know that you speak and teach rightly. Regarding the word, they speak truly indeed, because John 17: "Your word is truth." They themselves were saying this by way of flattery, so that they might extract the secret of his heart from him. Whence Chrysostom: "This is the first prudence of hypocrites: feigned praise, just as one who cannot subdue a bull by strength rubs its neck with gentle hands, so as to seize it through blandishments." And concerning such persons, Proverbs 16: "An evil man entices his friend and leads him along a way that is not good"; and Proverbs 27: "He who blesses his neighbor with a loud voice, rising in the night, shall be likened to one who curses."